Structural transitions in biomolecules - a numerical comparison of two approaches for the study of phase transitions in small systems

Nelson A. Alves,U.H.E. Hansmann,Y. Peng

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.cond-mat/0201498

2002-01-28

Abstract:We compare two recently proposed methods for the characterization of phase transitions in small systems. The usefulness of these techniques is evaluated for the case of structural transition in alanine-based peptides.

Statistical Mechanics,Soft Condensed Matter,Quantitative Biology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the paper attempts to solve

This paper aims to evaluate and compare two newly proposed methods for studying phase transitions in small systems. Specifically, the author hopes to use these methods to characterize structural transitions in biomolecules, especially the helix - coil transition in polyalanine. The following are the specific problems that the paper attempts to solve:

1. **Evaluate the effectiveness of the two methods**:
- **Borrmann method**: Classify phase transitions by calculating the density of complex zeros in a finite system.
- **Janke - Kenna (JK) method**: Use the cumulative distribution density of zeros to determine the order and intensity of phase transitions.

2. **Verify the applicability of these methods in small systems**:
- A small system refers to a system of finite size, such as a polypeptide chain in a biomolecule, which is very small in size compared to a macroscopic system.
- The author is particularly concerned with whether these methods can be effectively applied to structural transitions in biomolecules, especially the helix - coil transition in polyalanine.

3. **Explore the phase - transition characteristics of different molecules**:
- In addition to polyalanine, the author also studied the phase - transition behavior of another more complex molecule, Ala_10 - Gly_5 - Ala_10, to further verify the applicability and reliability of these methods.

4. **Provide benchmark tests**:
- Use the results of previous independent studies as benchmarks to evaluate the ability of these two methods to identify phase transitions in small systems and point out the difficulties that may be encountered when applying these classification schemes.

### Formula summary

The main formulas involved in the paper are as follows:

- **Partition function**:
\[
Z(\beta)=\sum_{E} n(E)\exp(-\beta E)
\]
where \(\beta = \frac{1}{k_B T}\), \(k_B\) is the Boltzmann constant, and \(T\) is the temperature.

- **Partition function of the discrete - energy model**:
\[
Z(u)=\sum_{E} n(E)u^E
\]
where \(u = \exp(-k\beta)\), \(k\) is an appropriately defined constant.

- **Linear distribution parameters of complex zeros**:
\[
\alpha_u=\frac{\ln\phi(\tau_3)-\ln\phi(\tau_2)}{\ln\tau_3-\ln\tau_2}
\]
\[
\gamma_u=\frac{\text{Re}(u_2)-\text{Re}(u_1)}{\tau_2 - \tau_1}
\]
where \(\phi(\tau_k)=\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{1}{|u_k - u_{k - 1}|}+\frac{1}{|u_{k+1}-u_k|}\right)\), \(\tau_k=\text{Im}(u_k)\).

- **Cumulative density formula of the JK method**:
\[
G_L(r_j)=\frac{2j - 1}{2L^d}
\]
In the thermodynamic limit, for a first - order phase transition:
\[
G_\infty(r)=g_\infty(0)r+ar^{w + 1}+\cdots
\]

- **Relationship between latent heat and slope**:
\[
\Delta e=k u_c\frac{2\pi}{a_1}
\]
where \(u_c=\exp(-k\beta_c)\).

Through these formulas and methods, the author hopes to accurately identify and characterize phase transitions in small systems, thereby providing new tools and insights for the study of biomolecular structural transitions.