Bowel preparation before elective right colectomy: Multitreatment machine-learning analysis on 2,617 patients
Marco Catarci,Stefano Guadagni,Francesco Masedu,Giacomo Ruffo,Massimo Giuseppe Viola,Marco Scatizzi,Italian ColoRectal Anastomotic Leakage (iCral) study group,Paolo Ciano,Michele Benedetti,Leonardo Antonio Montemurro,Marco Clementi,Elisa Bertocchi,Gaia Masini,Amedeo Altamura,Francesco Rubichi,Marco Migliore,Daniele Parlanti,Gabriele Vago,Antonio Sciuto,Ugo Pace,Andrea Fares Bucci,Michele Simone,Diletta Cassini,Lorenzo Pandolfini,Alessandro Falsetto,Ferdinando Ficari,Francesco Giudici,Fabio Cianchi,Alberto Patriti,Marcella Lodovica Ricci,Walter Siquini,Alessandro Cardinali,Stefano D'Ugo,Marcello Spampinato,Stefano Scabini,Alessandra Aprile,Domenico Soriero,Marco Caricato,Gabriella Teresa Capolupo,Giusto Pignata,Jacopo Andreuccetti,Ilaria Canfora,Andrea Liverani,Giuseppe Lamacchia,Claudia Franceschilli,Roberto Campagnacci,Angela Maurizi,Pierluigi Marini,Grazia Maria Attinà,Ugo Elmore,Francesco Puccetti,Francesco Corcione,Umberto Bracale,Roberto Peltrini,Roberto Santoro,Pietro Amodio,Massimo Carlini,Domenico Spoletini,Rosa Marcellinaro,Antonio Giuliani,Giovanni Del Vecchio,Mario Sorrentino,Massimo Stefanoni,Giovanni Ferrari,Pietro Maria Lombardi,Alberto Di Leo,Lorenzo Crepaz,Augusto Verzelli,Andrea Budassi,Giuseppe Sica,Giulia Bagaglini,Stefano Rausei,Silvia Tenconi,Davide Cavaliere,Leonardo Solaini,Giorgio Ercolani,Gian Luca Baiocchi,Sarah Molfino,Marco Milone,Giovanni Domenico De Palma,Giovanni Ciaccio,Paolo Locurto,Giovanni Domenico Tebala,Antonio Di Cintio,Luigi Boni,Elisa Cassinott,Stefano Mancini,Andrea Sagnotta,Mario Guerrieri,Monica Ortenzi,Roberto Persiani,Alberto Biondi,Andrea Lucchi,Giulia Vitali,Dario Parini,Maurizio De Luca,Antonino Spinelli,Francesco Carrano,Michele Genna,Francesca Fior,Vincenzo Bottino,Antonio Ferronetti,Andrea Coratti,Giuseppe Giuliani,Roberto Benigni,Dario Scala,Battistino Puppio,Alessio Vagliasindi,Andrea Muratore,Patrizia Marsanic,Nicoletta Sveva Pipitone Federico,Maurizio Pavanello,Carlo Di Marco,Umberto Rivolta,Camillo Leonardo Bertoglio,Micaela Piccoli,Francesca Pecchini,Carlo Talarico,Vincenzo Greco,Alessandro Carrara,Michele Motter,Giuseppe Tirone,Mauro Totis,Nicolò Tamini,Franco Roviello,Riccardo Piagnerelli,Alessandro Anastasi,Giuseppe Canonico,Gianluca Guercioni,Simone Cicconi,Giuseppe Maria Ettorre,Marco Colasanti,Mauro Montuori,Enrico Pinotti,Pierpaolo Mariani,Roberta Carminati,Nicolò de Manzini,Edoardo Osenda,Annibale Donini,Luigina Graziosi,Mariano Fortunato Armellino,Ciro De Martino,Lucio Taglietti,Arianna Birindelli,Gabriele Anania,Matteo Chiozza,Mariantonietta Di Cosmo,Daniele Zigiotto,Carlo Vittorio Feo,Fioralba Pindozzi,Paolo Millo,Manuela Grivon,Corrado Pedrazzani,Cristian Conti,Silvio Guerriero,Lorenzo Organetti,Andrea Costanzi,Michela Monteleone,Nereo Vettoretto,Emanuele Botteri,Federico Marchesi,Giorgio Dalmonte,Massimo Basti,Diletta Frazzini,Graziano Longo,Simone Santoni,Moreno Cicetti,Gabriele La Gioia,Giuseppe Brisinda,Stefano Berti
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surg.2024.08.039
IF: 4.348
Surgery
Abstract:Background: In the worldwide, real-life setting, some candidates for right colectomy still receive no bowel preparation, some receive oral antibiotics alone, some receive mechanical bowel preparation alone, and some receive mechanical bowel preparation with oral antibiotics, with varying degrees of compliance to preoperative intravenous antibiotic prophylaxis. Previous studies mainly focused on left-sided colorectal anastomoses while less attention has been devoted to right-sided ileocolic anastomoses. When high-level evidence from randomized clinical trials is lacking, multiple-treatment propensity score weighting analysis of prospective data on the basis of generalized boosted model is superior to a simple propensity score-matching analysis and to an inverse probability weighting in terms of external validity and bias reduction. Methods: This is an analysis on the basis of machine-learning procedures of 2,617 patients who underwent elective right colectomies. Results: The risk of surgical-site infections (5.0% after no bowel preparation) was significantly lower after mechanical bowel preparation with oral antibiotics (4.0%, P = .017), significantly greater after mechanical bowel preparation alone (8.6%, P = .019), and comparable after oral antibiotics alone (3.9%). The risk of anastomotic leakage (3.2% after no bowel preparation) was significantly greater after oral antibiotics alone (4.8%, P = .013). Concerning secondary outcomes, no significant differences were recorded for the risk of overall morbidity and reoperation. The risk of readmission (3.0% after no bowel preparation) was significantly reduced after mechanical bowel preparation with oral antibiotics (1.5%, P = .046), and the risk of major morbidity (5.1% after no bowel preparation) was significantly greater after oral antibiotics alone (6.7%, P = .007). Conclusion: This multitreatment machine-learning analysis, despite some limitations, showed that mechanical bowel preparation with oral antibiotics is associated with a decrease in surgical-site infections after elective right colectomy compared with no bowel preparation.