Direct evidence for a multiple superconducting gap in MgB2 from high-resolution photoemission spectroscopy

S. Tsuda,T. Yokoya,T. Kiss,Y.Takano,K. Togano,H. Kitou,H. Ihara,S. Shin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.87.177006

2001-04-25

Abstract:We study the new binary intermetallic superconductor MgB2 using high-resolution photo-emission spectroscopy. The superconducting-state spectrum measured at 5.4 K shows a coherent peak with a shoulder structure, in sharp contrast to that expected from a simple isotropic-gap opening. The spectrum can be well reproduced using the weighted sum of two Dynes functions with the gap sizes of 1.7 and 5.6 meV. Temperature-dependent study shows that both gaps close at the bulk transition temperature. These results provide spectroscopic evidence for a multiple gap of MgB2.

Superconductivity

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to study the superconducting gap characteristics of the binary inter - metallic superconductor MgB₂. Specifically, the authors carried out detailed measurements of the electronic structure of MgB₂ in the superconducting state through high - resolution photoemission spectroscopy technology. The main problem of the research is to verify whether MgB₂ has a single isotropic superconducting gap or multiple superconducting gaps.

### Research Background
Since MgB₂ was discovered to have a superconducting transition temperature of 39 K, it has attracted great attention. This transition temperature is not only the highest among inter - metallic compounds, but even exceeds that of some copper - based high - temperature superconductors. Although the superconducting mechanism of MgB₂ is considered to be phonon - mediated, its superconducting transition temperature is much higher than the upper limit predicted by the traditional BCS theory. Therefore, studying the superconducting gap characteristics of MgB₂ is of great significance for understanding its high superconducting transition temperature.

### Experimental Methods
The researchers used high - density MgB₂ samples and carried out measurements at different temperatures through high - resolution photoemission spectroscopy technology. The energy resolution used in the experiment was 3.8 meV, and the sample temperatures were 5.4 K (superconducting state) and 45 K (normal state).

### Main Findings
1. **Spectral Characteristics in the Superconducting State**:
- At 5.4 K, the superconducting - state spectral line shows an obvious peak at about 7 meV.
- The spectral line also shows a shoulder structure at about 3.5 meV. These features are not in line with the simple isotropic superconducting gap model.

2. **Multi - Gap Fitting**:
- When using a single Dynes function to fit the experimental data, it is impossible to fit the peak and the shoulder structure simultaneously.
- By introducing the weighted sum of two Dynes functions, corresponding to the larger gap (5.6 meV) and the smaller gap (1.7 meV) respectively, the experimental data can be well fitted.

3. **Temperature Dependence**:
- The analysis of temperature dependence shows that both gaps close near the bulk - phase transition temperature (36.5 K).
- The change of the smaller gap with temperature is in line with the prediction of BCS theory, while the larger gap drops more rapidly.

### Conclusion
This research provides direct evidence that the superconducting gap of MgB₂ is not a single isotropic gap, but a multi - gap structure with two main components. This result is consistent with previous transport measurements and other experimental results, further supporting the view that MgB₂ has multi - gap characteristics.

### Formulas
- **Dynes Function**:
\[
D(E,\Delta,\Gamma)=\Re\left\{\frac{E - i\Gamma}{\sqrt{(E - i\Gamma)^2-\Delta^2}}\right\}
\]
where \(E\) is energy, \(\Delta\) is the gap size, and \(\Gamma\) is the thermal broadening parameter.

- **Weighted Sum of Two Dynes Functions**:
\[
D_{L + S}=\frac{1}{1 + R}D_L(E,\Delta_L,\Gamma)+\frac{R}{1 + R}D_S(E,\Delta_S,\Gamma)
\]
where \(R\) is the amplitude ratio of the smaller gap to the larger gap, and \(\Delta_L\) and \(\Delta_S\) are the larger and smaller gap values respectively.

These findings are not only helpful for understanding the superconducting mechanism of MgB₂, but also provide an important reference for the research of other multi - band superconducting materials.