Christopher L. Henley
Abstract:What is the zero-temperature ordering pattern of a Heisenberg antiferromagnet with large spin length $S$ (and possibly small dilution), on the kagome lattice, or others built from corner-sharing triangles and tetrahedra? First, I summarize the uses of effective Hamiltonians to resolve the large ground-state degeneracy, leading to long-range order of the usual kind. Secondly, I discuss the effects of dilution, in particular to {\it non}-frustration of classical ground states, in that every simplex of spins is optimally satisfied. Of three explanations for this, the most complete is Moessner-Chalker constraint-counting. Quantum zero-point energy may compete with classical exchange energy in a diluted system, creating frustration and enabling a spin-glass state. I suggest that the regime of over 97% occupation is qualitatively different from the more strongly diluted regime.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the zero - temperature ordered pattern of Heisenberg antiferromagnets in the kagomé lattice and its similar structures, especially under the condition of large spin length \( S \) and possible small dilution. Specifically, the research focuses on the following two main issues:
1. **Effective Hamiltonian and Degeneracy Lifting**
- How to analyze a large number of degenerate ground states through the effective Hamiltonian, thus leading to long - range order.
- How quantum fluctuations affect the classical ground state and may lead to the "disorder - induced order" phenomenon.
2. **Dilution Effect**
- The effect of dilution (i.e., some magnetic sites are replaced by non - magnetic sites) on these highly frustrated systems.
- Whether dilution will generate a spin - glass state, or whether it will produce an effective Hamiltonian favorable for long - range order, or whether it will retain the special degeneracy of the pure lattice.
### Specific Problem Description
#### 1. Effective Hamiltonian and Degeneracy Lifting
The author explores how to use the effective Hamiltonian to analyze a large number of degenerate ground states, thus leading to long - range order. Especially for Heisenberg antiferromagnets with large spin length \( S \), at low temperatures, the degeneracy of the ground state of the system is very high, and these degenerate states need to be further analyzed by quantum fluctuations. For example, for the kagomé lattice, the classical ground state is coplanar, but the harmonic approximation cannot completely break this degeneracy, so a higher - order effective Hamiltonian is required to analyze the remaining degeneracy.
#### 2. Dilution Effect
The author discusses in detail the effect of dilution on these highly frustrated systems. Specifically:
- In the case of weak dilution, defects will introduce slowly varying spin distortions, similar to the spatial dependence of pseudo - dipoles.
- In the case of strong dilution, when the system is close to the percolation threshold, the typical path connecting two sites becomes fragile, resulting in an ordered state propagating on a one - dimensional chain.
- In the double - simplex lattice, even under strong dilution conditions, almost all simplices still remain to satisfy the condition \( L_\alpha = 0 \), which is different from ordinary frustrated lattices.
### Conclusion
The author proposes that the regime with an occupancy rate of more than 97% is significantly different in nature from the more strongly diluted regime. In addition, the author also proposes three reasons for explaining the satisfaction of the condition by simplices and discusses the combined effects of quantum fluctuations, dilution, unequal exchange constants, anisotropy, and external fields.
### Formula Summary
- Hamiltonian expression:
\[
H = J \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} \mathbf{S}_i \cdot \mathbf{S}_j
\]
- Total spin of simplex:
\[
L_\alpha \equiv \sum_{i \in \alpha} \mathbf{s}_i
\]
- Total spin of diluted simplex (considering different couplings):
\[
L_\alpha \equiv \sum_{i \in \alpha} w_{\alpha i} \mathbf{s}_i
\]
where \( w_{\alpha i} = J'/J \) when \( \alpha \) is a tetrahedron and \( i \) is a linked - layer spin, otherwise \( w_{\alpha i} = 1 \).
Through these formulas and analyses, the author deeply explores the effect of dilution on antiferromagnets in the kagomé lattice and its similar structures and provides insights supported by theory and simulation.