Non-Coplanar Magnetic Orders in Classical Square-Kagome Antiferromagnets

Martin Gembé,Heinz-Jürgen Schmidt,Ciarán Hickey,Johannes Richter,Yasir Iqbal,Simon Trebst

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.5.043204

2023-11-30

Abstract:Motivated by the recent synthesis of a number of Mott insulating square-kagome materials, we explore the rich phenomenology of frustrated magnetism induced by this lattice geometry, also referred to as the squagome or shuriken lattice. On the classical level, square-kagome antiferromagnets are found to exhibit extensive degeneracies, order-by-disorder, and non-coplanar ordering tendencies, which we discuss for an elementary, classical Heisenberg model with nearest-neighbor and cross-plaquette interactions. Having in mind that upon introducing quantum fluctuations non-coplanar order can melt into chiral quantum spin liquids, we provide detailed information on the multitude of non-coplanar orders, including some which break rotational symmetry (possibly leading to nematic quantum orders), as well as a number of (incommensurate) spin spiral phases. Using extensive numerical simulations, we also discuss the thermodynamic signatures of these phases, which often show multi-step thermal ordering. Our comprehensive discussion of the classical square-kagome Heisenberg model, often drawing comparisons to the conventional kagome antiferromagnet, sets the stage for future explorations of quantum analogs of the various phases, either conceptually such as in quantum spin-1/2 generalizations of our model or experimentally such as in the Cu-based candidate materials.

Strongly Correlated Electrons,Statistical Mechanics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the rich and complex magnetic phenomena caused by this lattice geometry in the classical square Kagome antiferromagnet. Specifically, the author focuses on:

1. **Non - coplanar magnetic order**: Study the non - coplanar magnetic order of the classical Heisenberg model in the square Kagome lattice under the nearest - neighbor and cross - octagonal interactions. These non - coplanar magnetic orders have scalar spin chirality, which can spontaneously break the Z2 symmetry and cause a finite - temperature phase transition in two - dimensional space.

2. **Degeneracy - lifting mechanism**: Explore the degeneracy - lifting mechanism (order - by - disorder) caused by thermal fluctuations or quantum fluctuations in these systems, that is, select a specific ordered state from a large number of degenerate ground states through thermal or quantum fluctuations.

3. **Multi - step thermal order**: Analyze the thermodynamic characteristics of these non - coplanar magnetic orders, especially the multi - step thermal order phenomena that they may exhibit during the cooling process.

4. **Comparison with the traditional Kagome lattice**: Reveal the unique properties of the square Kagome lattice by comparing it with the traditional Kagome antiferromagnet.

5. **Quantum analogy**: Lay the foundation for future quantum simulation and experimental research, especially explore the chiral quantum spin liquid that these non - coplanar magnetic orders may evolve into under quantum fluctuations.

### Formula presentation

1. **Hamiltonian expression**:
\[
H=\sum_{\langle i, j\rangle\in a}J_a\mathbf{S}_i\cdot\mathbf{S}_j
\]
where \(a = \{1, 2, 3\}\) represents three different types of bonds, as shown in Figure 1.

2. **Rewrite Hamiltonian**:
\[
H=\sum_{i, j, k\in\triangle}\left[\frac{1}{2}\left(\sqrt{\frac{J_1J_3}{J_2}}\mathbf{S}_i+\sqrt{\frac{J_1J_2}{J_3}}\mathbf{S}_j+\sqrt{\frac{J_2J_3}{J_1}}\mathbf{S}_k\right)^2-\frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{J_1J_3}{J_2}+\frac{J_1J_2}{J_3}+\frac{J_2J_3}{J_1}\right)\right]
\]

3. **Constraint condition**:
\[
\sqrt{\frac{J_1J_3}{J_2}}\mathbf{S}_i+\sqrt{\frac{J_1J_2}{J_3}}\mathbf{S}_j+\sqrt{\frac{J_2J_3}{J_1}}\mathbf{S}_k = 0
\]

4. **Parameter region**:
\[
- 2\leq\frac{J_2J_3}{J_1^2}-\left(\frac{J_2}{J_3}+\frac{J_3}{J_2}\right)\leq+ 2
\]

5. **Low - temperature specific heat**:
\[
c_V\rightarrow\begin{cases}
1 & \text{for the general two - dimensional Heisenberg model}\\
11/12 & \text{for the cooperative paramagnetic phase}\\
10/12 & \text{for the UUD state near the critical point}
\end{cases}
\]

### Summary

This paper explores the non - coplanar magnetic order and its thermodynamic characteristics in the square Kagome lattice through detailed theoretical analysis and numerical simulation. These studies not only provide a new perspective for understanding complex magnetic phenomena, but also for the future.