Mathematical investigation of the Boltzmann collisional operator

C.Y. Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.physics/0006038

2005-11-12

Abstract:Problems associated with the Boltzmann collisional operator are unveiled and discussed. By careful investigation it is shown that collective effects of molecular collisions in the six-dimensional position and velocity space are more sophisticated than they appear to be.

Fluid Dynamics,Data Analysis, Statistics and Probability

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to solve several key problems related to the Boltzmann collision operator, which are of great significance in classical statistical mechanics. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Complexity of collective effects**: The paper points out that the collective effects of molecular collisions in the six - dimensional phase space (i.e., position and velocity space) are much more complex than they seem on the surface. These effects not only affect the velocity distribution of molecules but also their position distribution, which has not been fully considered in the traditional Boltzmann equation.

2. **Paradox of time reversibility and irreversibility**: A central problem of the Boltzmann equation is that it seems to violate the principle of time reversibility. The Boltzmann equation itself is time - irreversible, while its derivation is based on the time reversibility of Newton's laws. This paradox has sparked extensive discussions and remains a research hotspot to this day.

3. **Definition problems of scattering cross - section**: The paper analyzes in detail the definition of the scattering cross - section \(\bar{\sigma}\) in the laboratory frame. The author points out that there are two main misunderstandings in the scattering cross - section defined according to the standard theory:
- Once \(dv'_1\) is specified, specifying \(dv'_2\) is redundant because there is an energy and momentum conservation relationship between \(v'_1\) and \(v'_2\).
- The scattering cross - section should be defined on the area element on the "accessible surface", not on the volume element \(dv'_1\). If we assume that \(dv'_1\) is a small sphere with a radius of \(r\), the scattering cross - section \(\bar{\sigma}\) will tend to infinity; if we assume that \(dv'_1\) is a slender cylinder, then \(\bar{\sigma}\) will tend to zero. Therefore, the definition of the scattering cross - section depends on the shape and size of \(dv'_1\) and is not a well - defined quantity.

4. **Direct calculation of molecular number changes**: The paper attempts to directly calculate the change in the number of molecules due to collisions without using the scattering cross - section \(\bar{\sigma}\). The author finds that even in this case, there are still some mathematical paradoxes, especially when dealing with the molecular distribution in the six - dimensional phase space.

5. **Importance of six - dimensional phase space**: The paper emphasizes that when studying the effects of molecular collisions, changes in both position and velocity must be considered simultaneously. The traditional Boltzmann equation mainly focuses on changes in velocity space and ignores changes in position space, which may lead to an incomplete understanding of collision effects.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to reveal the problems existing in the Boltzmann collision operator and propose the need to consider the collective effects of molecular collisions more comprehensively in the six - dimensional phase space.