Abstract:Background: Many authors have proposed Quantitative Theories of Consciousness (QTC) based on theoretical principles like information theory, Granger causality and complexity. Recently, Virmani and Nagaraj (arXiv:1608.08450v2 [cs.IT]) noted the similarity between Integrated Information and Compression-Complexity, and on this basis, proposed a novel measure of network complexity called Phi-Compression Complexity (Phi-C or $\Phi^C$). Their computer simulations using Boolean networks showed that $\Phi^C$ compares favorably to Giulio Tononi et al's Integrated Information measure $\Phi$ 3.0 and exhibits desirable mathematical and computational characteristics. Methods: In the present work, $\Phi^C$ was measured for two types of simulated networks: (A) Networks representing simple neuronal connectivity motifs (presented in Fig.9 of Tononi and Sporns, BMC Neuroscience 4(1), 2003); (B) random networks derived from Erd\"os-R \'enyi G(N, p)graphs. Code for all simulations was written in Python 3.6, and the library NetworkX was used to simulate the graphs. Results and discussions summary: In simulations A, for the same set of networks, $\Phi^C$ values differ from the values of IIT 1.0 $\Phi$ in a counter-intuitive manner. It appears that $\Phi^C$ captures some invariant aspects of the interplay between information integration, network topology, graph composition and node entropy. While Virmani and Nagaraj (arXiv:1608.08450v2 [cs.IT]) sought to highlight the correlations between $\Phi^C$ and IIT $\Phi$, the results of simulations A highlight the differences between the two measures in the way they capture the integrated information. In simulations B, the results of simulations A are extended to the more general case of random networks. In the concluding section we outline the novel aspects of this paper, and our ongoing and future research.

Some Techniques for the Measurement of Complexity in Tierra

Methods to Estimate Cryptic Sequence Complexity

Learning and Complexity in Genetic Auto-Adaptive Systems

Improved Measures of Integrated Information

Incoherence: A Generalized Measure of Complexity to Quantify Ensemble Divergence in Multi-Trial Experiments and Simulations

Measuring and understanding information storage and transfer in a simulated human gut microbiome

How Turing parasites expand the computational landscape of digital life

Measuring logic complexity can guide pattern discovery in empirical systems

Quantifying the intricacies of biological pattern formation: A new perspective through complexity measures

Measuring Complexity in an Aquatic Ecosystem

Statistical measures of complexity applied to ecological networks

Complexity measurement of natural and artificial languages

Quantifying Complexity: An Object-Relations Approach to Complex Systems

Set-based complexity and biological information

Network Complexity of Foodwebs

Simulation Study of Two Measures of Integrated Information

Measurements of collective machine intelligence

A Decomposition Method for Global Evaluation of Shannon Entropy and Local Estimations of Algorithmic Complexity

Information Erasure Lurking Behind Measures of Complexity

Measuring Complexity in Cantor Dynamics

Complexity of Networks