Abstract:Abstract. Spatiotemporal paleoclimate reconstructions that seek to estimate climate conditions over the last several millennia are derived from multiple climate proxy records (e.g., tree rings, ice cores, corals, and cave formations) that are heterogeneously distributed across land and marine environments. Assessing the skill of the methods used for these reconstructions is critical as a means of understanding the spatiotemporal uncertainties in the derived reconstruction products. Traditional statistical measures of skill have been applied in past applications, but they often lack formal null hypotheses that incorporate the spatiotemporal characteristics of the fields and allow for formal significance testing. More recent attempts have developed assessment metrics to evaluate the difference of the characteristics between two spatiotemporal fields. We apply these assessment metrics to results from synthetic reconstruction experiments based on multiple climate model simulations to assess the skill of four reconstruction methods. We further interpret the comparisons using analysis of empirical orthogonal functions (EOFs) that represent the noise-filtered climate field. We demonstrate that the underlying features of a targeted temperature field that can affect the performance of CFRs include the following: (i) the characteristics of the eigenvalue spectrum, namely the amount of variance captured in the leading EOFs; (ii) the temporal stability of the leading EOFs; (iii) the representation of the climate over the sampling network with respect to the global climate; and (iv) the strength of spatial covariance, i.e., the dominance of teleconnections, in the targeted temperature field. The features of climate models and reconstruction methods identified in this paper demonstrate more detailed assessments of reconstruction methods and point to important areas of testing and improving real-world reconstruction methods.

Reconstructing past temperatures from natural proxies and estimated climate forcings using short- and long-memory models

Uncertainties in the atmospheric loading to ice-sheet deposition for volcanic aerosols and implications for forcing reconstruction

Extracting Common Pulse-Like Signals from Multiple Ice Core Time Series

On Discriminating between GCM Forcing Configurations Using Bayesian Reconstructions of Late-Holocene Temperatures*

Long-memory effects in linear-response models of Earth's temperature and implications for future global warming

Efficient Reconstructions of Common Era Climate via Integrated Nested Laplace Approximations

A Methodology for Robust Multiproxy Paleoclimate Reconstructions and Modeling of Temperature Conditional Quantiles

Evaluation of statistical climate reconstruction methods based on pseudoproxy experiments using linear and machine learning methods

Northern Hemisphere Temperature Reconstruction During the Last Millennium Using Multiple Annual Proxies

Fast and Slow Climate Responses to CO2 and Solar Forcing: A Linear Multivariate Regression Model Characterizing Transient Climate Change

Separating Anthropogenically‐ and Naturally‐Caused Temperature Trends: A Systematic Approach Based on Climate Memory Analysis

Resolving the differences in the simulated and reconstructed temperature response to volcanism

A pseudoproxy assessment of why climate field reconstruction methods perform the way they do in time and space

A Bayesian spatiotemporal model for reconstructing climate from multiple pollen records

Decadal attribution of historic temperature and ocean heat content change to anthropogenic emissions

Empirical estimation of anthropogenic and natural contributions to surface air temperature trends at different latitudes

Conditional multi-step attribution for climate forcings

Forced signal and predictability in a prototype climate model: Implications for fingerprinting based detection in the presence of multidecadal natural variability

Quantifying Age and Model Uncertainties in Paleoclimate Data and Dynamical Climate Models with a Joint Inferential Analysis

Estimating Summer Arctic Warming Amplitude Relative to Pre-Industrial Levels Using Tree Rings

Probing the timescale dependency of local and global variations in surface air temperature from climate simulations and reconstructions of the last millennia