The Role of Type III Factors in Quantum Field Theory

Jakob Yngvason

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/S0034-4877%2805%2980009-6

2004-12-05

Abstract: One of von Neumann's motivations for developing the theory of operator algebras and his and Murray's 1936 classification of factors was the question of possible decompositions of quantum systems into independent parts. For quantum systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom the simplest possibility, i.e., factors of type I in the terminology of Murray and von Neumann, are perfectly adequate. In relativistic quantum field theory (RQFT), on the other hand, factors of type III occur naturally. The same holds true in quantum statistical mechanics of infinite systems. In this brief review some physical consequences of the type III property of the von Neumann algebras corresponding to localized observables in RQFT and their difference from the type I case will be discussed. The cumulative effort of many people over more than 30 years has established a remarkable uniqueness result: The local algebras in RQFT are generically isomorphic to the unique, hyperfinite type ${\rm III}_{1}$ factor in Connes' classification of 1973. Specific theories are characterized by the net structure of the collection of these isomorphic algebras for different space-time regions, i.e., the way they are embedded into each other.

Mathematical Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper attempts to explore why in Relativistic Quantum Field Theory (RQFT), the von Neumann algebras corresponding to local observables are usually type III factors rather than type I factors. Specifically, the paper discusses the following points:

1. **Background and Motivation**:
- Von Neumann and his collaborator Murray classified operator algebras in 1936. Among them, type I factors are applicable to quantum systems with finite degrees of freedom.
- However, in relativistic quantum field theory, type III factors occur naturally. This also applies to quantum statistical mechanics of infinite systems.

2. **Physical Significance**:
- Type III factors have special properties. For example, every projection \( E \in M \) can be written in the form of \( WW^* \), where \( W \) is an isometric operator. This property means that any state can be transformed into an eigenstate of a certain projection through specific local operations without disturbing the states in the causal complement.
- Such a property has important physical significance in RQFT, especially when dealing with causality and locality issues.

3. **Uniqueness Results**:
- After more than 30 years of research, it has been found that the local algebras in RQFT are usually isomorphic to the unique hyperfinite type III_1 factor classified by Connes in 1973.
- The specific theory is characterized by the embedding ways of these isomorphic algebras in the network structure.

4. **Fermi Thought Experiment**:
- The paper illustrates the limitations of the type I framework by analyzing Fermi's thought experiment (the interaction between two atoms). Under the type I framework, some analyses may lead to the false appearance of super - luminal propagation.
- By introducing the framework of RQFT, especially the properties of type III, this causality problem can be avoided.

5. **Historical Development**:
- From the early discussions to the later specific results, the paper reviews the development process of the local algebra structure in RQFT, including the contributions of Araki, Borchers, Powers, etc.

In summary, this paper aims to explain why in RQFT, the von Neumann algebras corresponding to local observables are usually type III factors, and to explore the physical significance and mathematical basis of this property.