Young people's experiences of physical activity insecurity: a qualitative study highlighting intersectional disadvantage in the UK

Caroline Dodd-Reynolds,Naomi Griffin,Phillippa Kyle,Steph Scott,Hannah Fairbrother,Eleanor Holding,Mary Crowder,Nicholas Woodrow,Carolyn Summerbell
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-024-18078-9
IF: 4.5
2024-03-15
BMC Public Health
Abstract:Abstract Background Intersecting socioeconomic and demographic reasons for physical activity (PA) inequalities are not well understood for young people at risk of experiencing marginalisation and living with disadvantage. This study explored young people’s experiences of PA in their local area, and the associated impacts on opportunities for good physical and emotional health and wellbeing. Methods Seven local youth groups were purposefully sampled from disadvantaged areas across urban, rural and coastal areas of England, including two that were specifically for LGBTQ + young people. Each group engaged in three interlinked focus groups which explored young people’s perceptions and lived experience of PA inequalities. Data were analysed using an inductive, reflexive thematic approach to allow for flexibility in coding. Results Fifty five young people aged 12–21 years of different sexualities, gender and ethnicity took part. Analysis yielded four themes: PA experiences across spaces; resigned to a lack of inclusivity and ‘belonging’; safety first; complexities in access and accessibility. Young people felt more comfortable to be active in spaces that were simpler to navigate, particularly outdoor locations largely based in nature. In contrast, local gyms and sports clubs, and the school environment in general, were spoken about often in negative terms and as spaces where they experienced insecurity, unsafety or discomfort. It was common for these young people to feel excluded from PA, often linked to their gender and sexuality. Lived experiences or fears of being bullied and harassed in many activity spaces was a powerful message, but in contrast, young people perceived their local youth club as a safe space. Intersecting barriers related to deprivation, gender and sexuality, accessibility, disability, Covid-19, affordability, ethnicity, and proximity of social networks. A need emerged for safe spaces in which young people can come together, within the local community and choose to be active. Conclusions The overarching concept of ‘physical activity insecurity’ emerged as a significant concern for the young people in this study. We posit that PA insecurity in this context can be described as a limited or restricted ability to be active, reinforced by worries and lived experiences of feeling uncomfortable, insecure, or unsafe.
public, environmental & occupational health
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily explores the inequalities faced by young people in the UK when engaging in local physical activity (PA) and introduces a concept called "physical activity insecurity." The study particularly focuses on young people who are socially marginalized and face various forms of disadvantage. ### Research Background - Currently, three-quarters of adolescents worldwide do not meet the global recommended standards for physical activity, leading to an estimated cost of over $67.5 billion annually due to inactivity. - In England, only 47% of adolescents aged 13 to 16 meet the national physical activity guidelines. - Despite the World Health Organization's global action plan to reduce the proportion of inactive people, there remains a knowledge gap in policy-making and implementation. Further understanding is needed on how to create supportive environments to encourage children and young people to actively participate in physical activity. ### Research Objectives - To explore the experiences of young people in socially disadvantaged positions when engaging in physical activity in their local areas, and the impact of these experiences on their physical and emotional well-being. - To specifically examine how factors such as gender, sexual orientation, and economic status intersect to influence these young people's opportunities to participate in physical activity. ### Key Findings - Young people are more inclined to engage in physical activity in natural environments, such as outdoor spaces, which are relatively accessible and comfortable. - Local gyms, sports clubs, and school environments are often described as negative spaces where young people feel uneasy or unsafe. - Gender and sexual orientation are major barriers to participating in physical activity, especially for transgender and non-binary individuals. - A sense of safety is a crucial factor in determining whether young people participate in physical activity, including both physical and psychological safety. - The availability and accessibility of physical activity are also affected by factors such as disability, the COVID-19 pandemic, economic burden, and race. - There is a need to create safe spaces where young people can freely choose to engage in physical activity within their communities. ### Conclusion The paper emphasizes the concept of "physical activity insecurity," which refers to a constrained ability due to discomfort, unease, or a sense of insecurity, limiting young people's potential to engage in physical activity. By gaining a deeper understanding of the specific experiences of young people from different socio-economic backgrounds in participating in physical activity, the paper calls on policymakers and society to work together to create more inclusive and supportive environments, ensuring that all young people have equal opportunities to participate in physical activity.