The Effects of Capital Controls on Housing Prices

Yang Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11146-024-09983-2

2024-04-06

The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics

Abstract:Policymakers increasingly use capital control policies (i.e., capital flow management) to manage capital flows. However, whether the implementation of such policies can effectively affect housing prices and to what extent is less discussed. In this paper, I study the effects of four types of granular capital control policies on housing prices using a large cross-country panel of 53 economies from 1995 to 2017. I find that the estimated effects of capital controls are distinct for different capital flow types and flow directions, but all capital control inflow indices appear to reduce housing prices in the long-run. Additionally, I find that capital controls have asymmetric effects on housing prices for advanced economies and emerging markets. The negative effects of capital controls on housing prices are mainly driven by pre-crisis subsample, which means capital controls have been in effect several times before the Global Financial Crisis. I also estimate the effects for boom and slump periods respectively and find that capital control policies are implemented in an acyclical way. Since there exists endogeneity for capital control on real estate transactions, I further use IPWRA method to rebalance capital control actions and find that IPWRA estimators can weaken the negative effects on housing prices, and the attenuation effects can be attributed to endogenous factors.

economics,business, finance,urban studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper examines the impact of capital control policies on housing prices. The study is based on data from 53 countries between 1995 and 2017, analyzing how four types of capital control policies (direct investment, financial credit, commercial credit, and real estate transactions) affect housing prices. The study finds that different types of capital inflow controls can lower housing prices in the long term, while the effects of capital outflow controls are not significant. In addition, there is asymmetry in the impact of capital control on housing prices between developed economies and emerging markets. The negative impact of capital control on housing prices is more significant before financial crises. The paper also points out that the implementation of capital control policies is often independent of economic cycles, but in some cases, inflow controls on direct investment and financial credit may be countercyclical. Due to the endogeneity issue in capital control in real estate transactions, the paper uses the inverse probability weighting regression adjustment estimator to mitigate this effect and finds that this method can weaken the negative effect of capital control on housing prices. In conclusion, the paper aims to fill the empirical evidence gap regarding the impact of capital control on housing prices and provide reference for relevant policy making.