Surface stratification determines the interfacial water structure of simple electrolyte solutions

Yair Litman,Kuo-Yang Chiang,Takakazu Seki,Yuki Nagata,Mischa Bonn

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41557-023-01416-6

IF: 24.274

2024-01-17

Nature Chemistry

Abstract:The distribution of ions at the air/water interface plays a decisive role in many natural processes. Several studies have reported that larger ions tend to be surface-active, implying ions are located on top of the water surface, thereby inducing electric fields that determine the interfacial water structure. Here we challenge this view by combining surface-specific heterodyne-detected vibrational sum-frequency generation with neural network-assisted ab initio molecular dynamics simulations. Our results show that ions in typical electrolyte solutions are, in fact, located in a subsurface region, leading to a stratification of such interfaces into two distinctive water layers. The outermost surface is ion-depleted, and the subsurface layer is ion-enriched. This surface stratification is a key element in explaining the ion-induced water reorganization at the outermost air/water interface.

chemistry, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the issue of the surface structure of electrolyte solutions, specifically investigating how the distribution of ions at the air/water interface affects the structure of interfacial water molecules. The traditional view holds that larger ions tend to congregate near the water surface, forming the so-called Electric Double Layer (EDL), thereby influencing the arrangement of interfacial water molecules. However, the authors of this paper challenge this traditional view by combining surface-specific heterodyne-detected vibrational sum frequency generation spectroscopy (HD-VSFG) with neural network-assisted ab initio molecular dynamics simulations (AIMD).

The key findings of the paper are as follows:
1. **Ion Distribution**: The authors found that in typical electrolyte solutions, ions are actually located a few angstroms (Å) below the water surface, rather than directly on the water surface. This results in the presence of two distinct water layer structures at the air/water interface: the outermost layer is ion-depleted, while the sub-surface layer is ion-enriched.
2. **Interfacial Layering Phenomenon**: This surface layering phenomenon is crucial for explaining the ion-induced rearrangement of water molecules, especially at the outermost air/water interface. It suggests that the traditional classifications of "surface enrichment" or "surface depletion" are overly simplistic, and the actual behavior is more complex.
3. **Challenge to Traditional EDL Model**: The paper shows that for most studied electrolytes (except HCl and NaClO4), the traditional EDL model cannot fully explain the HD-VSFG spectra. This implies that the relationship between ion distribution and water molecule structure is more subtle than previously thought.
4. **Methodological Advances**: By combining high-precision experimental techniques with theoretical simulations, the paper provides new insights into the understanding of liquid surfaces, particularly regarding the surface structure of electrolyte solutions and their implications for environmental chemistry and climate science.

In summary, the main goal of the paper is to improve our understanding of the surface structure of electrolyte solutions by providing new insights into ion distribution at the air/water interface, revealing that the traditional EDL model is insufficient to describe these complex surface phenomena.