Retrieval of High-Resolution Soil Moisture through Combination of Sentinel-1 and Sentinel-2 Data

Chunfeng Ma,Xin Li,Matthew F. McCabe
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rs12142303
IF: 5
2020-07-17
Remote Sensing
Abstract:Estimating soil moisture based on synthetic aperture radar (SAR) data remains challenging due to the influences of vegetation and surface roughness. Here we present an algorithm that simultaneously retrieves soil moisture, surface roughness and vegetation water content by jointly using high-resolution Sentinel-1 SAR and Sentinel-2 multispectral imagery, with an application directed towards the provision of information at the precision agricultural scale. Sentinel-2-derived vegetation water indices are investigated and used to quantify the backscatter resulting from the vegetation canopy. The proposed algorithm then inverts the water cloud model to simultaneously estimate soil moisture and surface roughness by minimizing a cost function constructed by model simulations and SAR observations. To examine the performance of VV- and VH-polarized backscatters on soil moisture retrievals, three retrieval schemes are explored: a single channel algorithm using VV (SCA-VV) and VH (SCA-VH) polarizations and a dual channel algorithm using both VV and VH polarizations (DCA-VVVH). An evaluation of the approach using a combination of a cosmic-ray soil moisture observing system (COSMOS) and Soil Climate Analysis Network measurements over Nebraska shows that the SCA-VV scheme yields good agreement at both the COSMOS footprint and single-site scales. The features of the algorithms that have the most impact on the retrieval accuracy include the vegetation water content estimation scheme, parameters of the water cloud model and the specification of initial ranges of soil moisture and roughness, all of which are comprehensively analyzed and discussed. Through careful consideration and selection of these factors, we demonstrate that the proposed SCA-VV approach can provide reasonable soil moisture retrievals, with RMSE ranging from 0.039 to 0.078 m3/m3 and R2 ranging from 0.472 to 0.665, highlighting the utility of SAR for application at the precision agricultural scale.
environmental sciences,imaging science & photographic technology,remote sensing,geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to estimate soil moisture with high precision by combining Sentinel - 1 SAR data and Sentinel - 2 multispectral images. Specifically, the research aims to overcome the influence of vegetation and surface roughness on radar backscattering signals in traditional methods, as these factors can significantly increase the uncertainty in soil moisture estimation. To achieve this goal, the authors propose a new algorithm that can simultaneously estimate soil moisture, surface roughness, and vegetation water content. By constructing a cost function and using an optimization algorithm to minimize this cost function, the simultaneous estimation of these parameters is achieved. ### Main problems to be solved 1. **Influence of vegetation and surface roughness**: Traditional soil moisture estimation methods based on SAR data are strongly influenced by vegetation and surface roughness, resulting in large uncertainties in the estimation results. The algorithm proposed in this paper can estimate these parameters more accurately by jointly using Sentinel - 1 SAR and Sentinel - 2 multispectral data, thereby improving the accuracy of soil moisture estimation. 2. **High - resolution soil moisture estimation**: Traditional remote sensing methods have limitations in providing high - resolution soil moisture estimation. By combining high - resolution Sentinel - 1 SAR data and Sentinel - 2 multispectral data, this paper aims to provide high - resolution soil moisture information suitable for precision agriculture. 3. **Simultaneous multi - parameter estimation**: Traditional soil moisture estimation algorithms can usually only estimate a single parameter, while the algorithm proposed in this paper can simultaneously estimate soil moisture, surface roughness, and vegetation water content, improving the practicality and accuracy of the algorithm. ### Method overview 1. **Data sources**: - **Sentinel - 1 SAR data**: Used to obtain radar backscattering signals, reflecting the comprehensive characteristics of soil and vegetation. - **Sentinel - 2 multispectral data**: Used to calculate the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and the Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI), and then estimate the Vegetation Water Content (VWC). 2. **Models and algorithms**: - **Water Cloud Model (WCM)**: Describes the backscattering behavior of the vegetation canopy. - **Oh model**: Describes the backscattering behavior of bare soil. - **Cost function**: Combines the simulation results of the WCM and Oh models with the actual SAR observation data to construct a cost function. - **Optimization algorithm**: Uses the Shuffled Complex Evolution University of Arizona (SCE - UA) algorithm to minimize the cost function, thereby simultaneously estimating soil moisture and surface roughness. 3. **Validation methods**: - **Ground measurement data**: Uses soil moisture measurement data from the United States Soil Climate Analysis Network (SCAN) sites and the Cosmic Ray Soil Moisture Observation System (COSMOS) sites for validation. - **Performance evaluation**: Evaluates the accuracy and applicability of the algorithm by comparing the performance of single - channel algorithms and dual - channel algorithms in different polarization modes (VV and VH). ### Conclusion By combining Sentinel - 1 SAR and Sentinel - 2 multispectral data, the algorithm proposed in this paper can provide high - resolution soil moisture estimation while considering the influence of vegetation and surface roughness. The experimental results show that the single - channel algorithm (SCA - VV) exhibits good consistency on multiple scales, with the RMSE ranging from 0.039 to 0.078 m³/m³ and the R² ranging from 0.472 to 0.665, demonstrating the potential of this method in precision agriculture applications.