Abstract:The field of paleogenomics (the study of ancient genomes) is rapidly advancing, with more robust methods of isolating ancient DNA and increasing access to next-generation DNA sequencing technology. As these studies progress, many important ethical issues have emerged that should be considered when ancient Native American remains, whom we refer to as ancestors, are used in research. We highlight a 2017 article by Kennett et al., "Archaeogenomic evidence reveals prehistoric matrilineal dynasty," that brings to light several ethical issues that should be addressed in paleogenomics research. The study helps elucidate the matrilineal relationships in ancient Chacoan society through ancient DNA analysis. However, we, as Indigenous researchers and allies, raise ethical concerns with the study's scientific conclusions that can be problematic for Native American communities: (1) the lack of tribal consultation, (2) the use of culturally insensitive descriptions, and (3) the potential impact on marginalized groups. Further, we explore the limitations of the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act, which addresses repatriation but not research, because clear ethical guidelines have not been established for research involving Native American ancestors, especially those deemed "culturally unaffiliated." Multiple studies of "culturally unaffiliated" remains have been initiated recently, so it is imperative that researchers consider the ethical ramifications of paleogenomics research. Past research indiscretions have created a history of mistrust and exploitation in many Native American communities. To promote ethical engagement of Native American communities in research, we therefore suggest careful attention to ethical considerations, strong tribal consultation requirements, and greater collaborations among museums, federal agencies, researchers, scientific journals, and granting agencies.

Ancient DNA from Maya ruins tells story of ritual human sacrifices

Ancient genomes reveal insights into ritual life at Chichén Itzá

Bioanthropological analysis of human remains from the archaic and classic period discovered in Puyil cave, Mexico

Archaeological, radiological, and biological evidence offer insight into Inca child sacrifice

Ancient genomics reveals a genetic continuum with dual structure in the Classic Copan

Burnt remains of Maya royalty mark a dramatic power shift

Demographic history and genetic structure in pre-Hispanic Central Mexico

The genomic and cultural diversity of the Inka Qhapaq hucha ceremony in Chile and Argentina

DNA from ancient graves reveals the culture of a mysterious nomadic people

Chaco Canyon Dig Unearths Ethical Concerns

[Mitochondrial DNA diversity in prehispanic bone remains on the eastern Colombian Andes]

A Probe into the Phenomenon of Human Sacrifice in the Neolithic Age in Chengdu Plain, China

Environmental DNA reveals arboreal cityscapes at the Ancient Maya Center of Tikal

Paleoecological Studies at the Ancient Maya Center of Yaxnohcah Using Analyses of Pollen, Environmental DNA, and Plant Macroremains

The Genetics of Mexico Recapitulates Native American Substructure and Affects Biomedical Traits

Ancient DNA analyses of two Early Chalcolithic Individuals from the West Mound

Going local with ancient DNA: A review of human histories from regional perspectives

Whole genome sequencing of 76 Mexican Indigenous reveals recent selection signatures linked to pathogens and diet adaptation.

Human ancient DNA analysis in Latin America: Current state and challenges

A commentary of "the intersection of archaeology and genomics: Sparking the advances in cognitive human society": 10 remarkable discoveries from 2020 in Nature

The coevolution of ritual and society: new 14C dates from ancient Mexico