How New Governance Shapes Changes in the Long-Term Care Sector in Ontario, Canada 1
Poland Lai
Abstract:ABSTRACTThis paper turns to the insights of New Governance in order to explain how law was used to promote innovations in health care governance in the Canadian province of Ontario between 2004 and 2012. New Governance refers to a family of approaches that are more flexible and less prescriptive. My research includes review of government documents, legislation and other sources in order to identify changes to regulation and governance. I also draw upon interviews with seven organizations in the sector, which were conducted as part of a larger project to help contextualize and explain the changes in law. I argue that, while the formal legal and regulatory apparatus continue to be used to regulate the provision of care and treatment, New Governance approaches represent additional processes and procedures to problem-solve challenges in the sector. Law is being used to formalize or strengthen these processes and procedures in order to allow long-term care home residents, families, friends, and workers to participate in problem-solving. This increasing emphasis on processes can be understood as an attempt to broaden the scope of possible solutions and changes that could be implemented in the sector. For future research, I suggest that more attention be paid to interrogating the relationships that enable New Governance techniques.Keywords: governance, regulation, experimentalism, long-term care, disability, innovation.IntroductionIn Canada, and around the world, public sector managers and their political masters continue to respond to challenges in their respective health care systems. According to the Institute of Public Administration of Canada, factors such as an aging population, increasing prevalence of chronic conditions, implementation of new technologies, and the introduction of new and costly pharmaceuticals contribute to the rising health care costs of provincial and territorial governments (Institute of Public Administration of Canada, 2013: 3). Most frequently, public discourse around health care is related to the level and quality of services, and the funding for such services. Colleen Flood explains the crisis talk in an Ontario context:In the end, recurrent political debates are reduced to issues of money, and the problems of the system are blamed on the lack of it. We believe, however, that the Ontario crisis in health care, along with similarly situated health care schemes, has more to do with an absence of effective governance (Flood, 2004: 170).One could ask how the literature on governance responds to current and future challenges in the health care system. By governance, I mean "the changing boundaries between the public, private and voluntary sectors, and the changing role of the state" (Rhodes, 2012: 33). This paper turns to the insights of New Governance in order to explain how law was used to promote innovations in health care governance in the Canadian province of Ontario between 2004 and 2012. New Governance consists of a range of processes and practices that are less rigid and less prescriptive: increased participation of non-state actors; public/private collaboration; diversity and competition within the market; decentralization; integration of policy domains; noncoerciveness (soft law); adaptability and constant learning; and coordination (Lobel, 2004a and 2012; de Burca and Scott, 2006). There is a shared concern within the literature about how New Governance transforms the way law is created and administered (Trubek, 2006: 246). For some scholars and policy makers, New Governance is positioned as an ambitious framework for addressing public policy problems, such as occupational safety, discrimination law in the workplace, financial regulation, and health care (Lobel, 2004a and 2012; Sturm, 2006a; NeJaime, 2009; Blum, 2007).This paper examines how recent changes to the governance of the long-term care (LTC) home sector in Ontario-especially participatory processes and procedures enshrined in law- can help meet some of the pressing challenges in the sector. …
Sociology,Law