A sampling scheme for quantifying and benchmarking on time performance of urban bus transit

Ramandeep Singh,Daniel J. Graham,Mark Trompet,John Barry
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tra.2023.103945
IF: 6.615
2024-01-25
Transportation Research Part A Policy and Practice
Abstract:In this paper we use large-scale mass transit data to improve the journey time performance measurement of urban bus systems. For low frequency bus services, the application of on-time performance (OTP) metrics, particularly the location and number of stops to sample, varies greatly across operators, which can lead to biased estimates. In this paper, we aim to address sampling disparity, and propose a new statistically robust sampling scheme to ensure representative, non-biased, and comparable measurement of route level on time performance (OTP) which enables the inclusion of operators with sparse data in benchmarking activities. We use automated vehicle location data and analyse 59 unique low frequency route-direction data sets from 9 international bus operators. Across all route-direction data sets, an average of 28% of stops are required to be sampled under the defined sampling scheme to achieve a 95% confidence level of sampling the route-level mean within a ± 5% range of accuracy. By including data on additional routes, the analysis can be further refined and generalised to enable progressive improvement of inter-operator comparability and benchmarking.
transportation,transportation science & technology,economics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?