Abstract:Background: Kidney transplant recipients with graft failure (KTR-GF) and those with a failing graft are an increasingly prevalent group of patients. Their clinical management is complex, and outcomes are worse than transplant naïve patients on dialysis. In 2023, the Kidney Disease: Improving Global Outcomes (KDIGO) organization reported findings from a controversies conference and identified several clinical practice priorities for KTR-GF. Objective: As an exercise in needs assessment, we aimed to collate and summarize current practices in adult Canadian kidney transplant programs around these KDIGO-identified clinical practice priorities. Design: Environmental scan followed by content analysis. Setting: Canadian adult kidney transplant programs. Measurements: We categorized the themes of our content analysis around 7 clinical practice priorities: (1) determining prognosis and kidney failure trajectory; (2) immunosuppression management; (3) management of medical complications; (4) preparing for return to dialysis; (5) evaluation and listing for re-transplantation; (6) management of psychological effects; and (7) transition to supportive care. Methods: We solicited documents that identified each program's current care practices for KTR-GF or patients with a failing graft, including policies, procedures, pathways, and protocols. A content analysis of documents and informal correspondence (email or telephone conversations) was done to extract information surrounding the 7 practice priorities. Results: Of the 18 programs contacted, 12 transplant programs participated in this study and a document from a provincial organization (where 2 non-responding programs are located) was procured and included in this analysis. Overall, practice gaps and discrepancies were noted. Many participants highlighted the lack of evidence or consensus to guide the management of KTR-GF as the key reason. Immunosuppression management was the most frequently addressed priority. Six programs and the provincial document recommended a nuanced approach to immunosuppressant management based on clinical factors and re-transplant candidacy. Two programs used the Kidney Failure Risk Equation and eGFR to determine referral trajectories and prepare patients for return to dialysis. Exact processes outlining medical management during the transition were not found except for nephrectomy indications and in 1 program that has a specific transition clinic for KTR-GF. All programs have a formal or informal policy that KTR-GF should be assessed for re-transplantation. Referrals for psychological support and transition to supportive care were made on a case-by-case basis. Limitations: Our environmental scan was at risk of non-response bias and restricted to transplant programs. Kidney clinics and dialysis units may have relevant policies and procedures that were not examined. Conclusion: The findings from our environmental scan suggest gaps in care and potential areas for quality improvement, including a lack of multidisciplinary care, structured dialysis preparation and psychological support. There is also a need to prioritize research that generates evidence to guide the management of KTR-GF and contributes to the aim of developing clinical practice guidelines.

Research Priority Setting in Kidney Disease: A Systematic Review

Research priorities for autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease: a UK priority setting partnership

Perceived Significance of Engagement in Research Prioritization Among Chronic Kidney Disease Patients, Caregivers, and Health Care Professionals: A Qualitative Study

Developing Consensus-Based Priority Outcome Domains for Trials in Kidney Transplantation: A Multinational Delphi Survey With Patients, Caregivers, and Health Professionals

Outcomes for clinical trials involving adults with chronic kidney disease: a multinational Delphi survey involving patients, caregivers and health professionals

Global Capacity for Clinical Research in Nephrology: a Survey by the International Society of Nephrology

A Patient-Prioritized Research Agenda for Clinical Trials in Kidney Stone Disease

An Environmental Scan of Canadian Kidney Transplant Programs for the Management of Patients With Graft Failure: A Research Letter

Prioritization of research engaged with rare disease stakeholders: a systematic review and thematic analysis

Operations Research to Solve Kidney Allocation Problems: A Systematic Review

Development of an international Delphi survey to establish core outcome domains for trials in adults with glomerular disease

Mind the Gap in Kidney Care: Translating What We Know into What We Do

Guidelines, Policies, and Barriers to Kidney Care: Findings from a Global Survey.

Identifying Outcomes Important to Patients with Glomerular Disease and Their Caregivers

A new era in the science and care of kidney diseases

Representation of Chronic Kidney Disease in Randomized Controlled Trials Among Patients With Heart failure With Reduced Ejection Fraction: A Systematic Review

Advancing Treatments for Rare Renal Diseases: New Hopes and Opportunities to Address a High Unmet Need.

Patient-Centered Research and Outcomes in Cancer and Kidney Transplantation

An International Delphi Survey Helped Develop Consensus-Based Core Outcome Domains for Trials in Peritoneal Dialysis

Top research priorities in liver and gallbladder disorders in the UK

Factors associated with health inequities in access to kidney transplantation in the USA: A scoping review