Accelerated Stability Testing in Food Supplements Underestimates Shelf Life Prediction of Resveratrol with Super-Arrhenius Behavior

Andrea Biagini,Nicola Refrigeri,Concetta Caglioti,Paola Sabbatini,Silvia Ticconi,Giada Ceccarelli,Rossana Giulietta Iannitti,Federico Palazzetti,Bernard Fioretti
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/sym16040493
2024-04-19
Symmetry
Abstract:Thermo-oxidative stability testing plays a critical role in accurately predicting shelf life. These tests are performed in real time and under stress conditions, where degradation processes are accelerated by increasing storage conditions. In this study, high-performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) analyses were performed to evaluate the degradation of resveratrol in nutraceutical tablets as a function of time under different storage conditions in terms of temperature and relative humidity (RH), namely 25 °C/60% RH, 30 °C/65% RH, and 40 °C/75% RH. The latter is an accelerated test and is used to estimate shelf life for long-term storage. Resveratrol is present in both pure form and as a solid dispersion on magnesium dihydroxide microparticles (Resv@MDH). Degradation kinetic constants were determined at 25 °C, 30 °C, and 40 °C, and the Arrhenius behavior of the kinetic constants as a function of temperature was verified. The main results of this work are as follows: (i) the stability of resveratrol in nutraceutical tablets is affected by temperature; (ii) the dependence of the kinetic constants on temperature does not follow the Arrhenius equation, determining an overestimation of the degradation rate at 25 °C; in this regard a modified version of the Arrhenius equation that takes into account the deviation from linearity has been used to estimate the dependence of the kinetic constant on the temperature. These results suggest that accelerated testing does not provide a general model for predicting the shelf life of foods and dietary supplements. The reason may be due to possible matrix effects that result in different degradation mechanisms depending on the temperature. In this regard, symmetry relationships in the kinetics of chemical reactions resulting from microscopic reversibility and their relationship to the deviation from the Arrhenius equation are discussed. However, further research is needed to characterize the degradation mechanisms at different temperatures. The results of these studies would allow accurate prediction of food degradation to improve food safety and risk management and reduce food waste. In addition, knowledge of stability processes is necessary to ensure the maintenance of physiological processes by dietary supplements.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to accelerate the accuracy of stability tests in predicting the shelf - life of resveratrol in food supplements. Specifically, the study found that accelerated stability tests underestimate the actual shelf - life of resveratrol under different storage conditions. Especially, accelerated tests conducted under high - temperature conditions will lead to an overestimation of the degradation rate of resveratrol stored at 25°C. The reason for this problem may be that under different temperature conditions, there are differences in the degradation mechanisms of resveratrol, resulting in its kinetic behavior deviating from the classical Arrhenius equation, showing super - Arrhenius behavior. ### Main research contents: 1. **Background and purpose**: - Thermo - oxidative stability tests play a crucial role in predicting the shelf - life of food supplements. These tests are usually carried out under real - time and stress conditions, and the degradation process is accelerated by improving the storage conditions. - This study aims to evaluate the degradation of resveratrol in nutraceutical tablets under different storage conditions (temperature and relative humidity), especially the stability of pure resveratrol and resveratrol loaded on magnesium hydroxide microparticles (Resv@MDH). 2. **Experimental methods**: - High - performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) was used to analyze the degradation of resveratrol under different storage conditions (25°C/60% RH, 30°C/65% RH, 40°C/75% RH). - By measuring the resveratrol content at different time points (0 months, 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, 24 months), the degradation kinetic constants were calculated. - Check whether the change of kinetic constants with temperature conforms to the Arrhenius equation, and use the modified Arrhenius equation to fit the data. 3. **Main results**: - The stability of resveratrol at different temperatures is significantly affected. - The change of kinetic constants with temperature does not conform to the Arrhenius equation, showing super - Arrhenius behavior. - The accelerated test (40°C/75% RH) overestimates the degradation rate of resveratrol at 25°C. 4. **Discussion**: - The non - Arrhenius behavior may be due to different degradation mechanisms occurring at different temperatures, such as second - order reactions or other mechanisms. - This finding indicates that accelerated stability tests cannot provide a general model to predict the shelf - life of food and dietary supplements. - Future research needs to further characterize the degradation mechanisms at different temperatures to improve the prediction accuracy of food degradation, improve food safety and risk management, and reduce food waste. ### Conclusion: This study reveals the limitations of accelerated stability tests in predicting the shelf - life of resveratrol, emphasizing the importance of conducting detailed degradation mechanism studies under different temperature conditions. This will help to improve the quality control and safety assessment of food supplements.