Abstract:Phonological-based instruction, namely phonological awareness instruction (PA) and phonics instruction, has shown to be effective on early literacy skills among young children in western countries. Children who learn English as a foreign language (EFL) learn to read English differently from children in English-dominant societies. Effectiveness of the instruction in the EFL context is much less investigated. The present study systematically reviewed 15 experimental and quasi-experimental studies published in between 2000 and 2016, on the topic of the effectiveness of phonological-based instruction in the EFL context. Study characteristics and instructional features were described, and effect sizes were calculated. Phonological-based instruction was consistently found to be effective among primary school EFL students on reading underlying skills, including phonemic awareness and non-word reading. The median value of the effect size was moderate. In contrast, the effectiveness on word recognition (lexical access and pronunciation) and reading comprehension were inconsistent across studies. The median value of the effect size on word reading was small. This pattern suggests a limitation of the phonological-based instruction, which is the difficulty of transferring the phonological underlying outcomes to real reading. We found that most studies, although meeting the minimum standards of evidence for effectiveness, suffer from methodological flaws; thus, they are potentially biased. Therefore, the positive effects reported in this study should be interpreted with caution. The implication for practice of this study is that including phonological-based instruction in the current English curriculum may be beneficial for young EFL students, thus they can better learn to phonologically decode English words. But not enough evidence has been found to support the instructional effectiveness on real word recognition and reading comprehension. Future research on this topic with rigorous design is needed so that strong causal inference can be made. The findings of this study provide novel insights into foreign language education of English for young learners.

The Effects of Phonics Instruction vs . Whole Language Approach on Korean Middle School Students ’ L 2 Vocabulary Learning

Action research of written language instruction methods for elementary English underachievers

Learning vocabulary from e-book reading and recorded word explanation for low-income elementary students with and without reading difficulties

Effects of Vocabulary Intervention by Subtypes of Elementary Students with Reading Difficulties

The Effectiveness of Phonological-Based Instruction in English As a Foreign Language Students at Primary School Level: A Research Synthesis

The Effectiveness of Phonics and Whole-word Techniques on Improving English Reading Skills of Dyslexic Students

Chinese EFL Teachers’ Perception and Practice of Phonics Instruction

The learning effects of student-constructed word cards as homework for the adolescent English Language classroom

Effects of Orthographic Input and Inhibitory Control on Second-Language Speech Production

The Effect of Phonemic Awareness on the Literacy Development of First Grade Children in a Traditional or a Whole Language Classroom

Effects of linguistic and affective variables on middle school students’ writing performance in the context of English as a foreign language: an approach using structural equation modeling

A corpus-based analysis of vocabulary usage in English writings by Korean elementary school students.

EFL in the elementary school: Literacy gap and intervention.

An analysis of the effects of English teaching and learning based on interactive read-alouds

Online Literacy Instruction for Young Korean Dual Language Learners in General Education

The effects of English language instruction for underachievers in elementary school on the affective domain

The effect of the proportion of illustrations on vocabulary acquisition for elementary school students

Systematic Phonics Instruction Helps Students Learn to Read: Evidence from the National Reading Panel’s Meta-Analysis

The Effectiveness of a Group Reading Instruction Program with Poor Readers in Multiple Grades

Effects of content support on integrated reading-writing task performance and incidental vocabulary learning

Effects of Two Teaching Strategies on Preschoolers’ Oral Language Skills: Repeated Read-Aloud With Question and Answer Teaching Embedded and Repeated Read-Aloud With Executive Function Activities Embedded