Heavy metal contamination risk assessment and correlation analysis of heavy metal contents in soil and crops

Mingtao Xiang,Yan Li,Jiayu Yang,Kaige Lei,Yi Li,Feng Li,Daofu Zheng,Xiaoqian Fang,Yu Cao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envpol.2021.116911
IF: 8.9
2021-06-01
Environmental Pollution
Abstract:<p>Heavy metal pollution is a notable threat to agricultural production. Soil heavy metal pollution can cause potential ecological risk (ERI), and crop heavy metal pollution can cause human health risk (HRI). However, most previous studies partially focused on heavy metal pollution in soil or crop but often neglected the relationship between them. Actually, soil heavy metal can pollute crops to some extent, while not all heavy metal pollution in crops comes from soil. The inner relationship of pollution risk in soil-crop system is worth attention. In this study, we selected Ningbo as the study region and used sample data to assess both soil and crop heavy metal risks, in order to explore the differences between heavy metal contamination risks in soil and crops as well as the relationships between heavy metal contents in soil and crops. Our results showed that Hg was the most polluted heavy metal in soil, which led to the highest ecological risk in Jiangbei (Comprehensive ERI = 567) with the maximum ERI of Hg (430). However, As in crops contributed the most to health risk and caused the highest health risk in Fenghua (HRI = 10) with the largest contribution of 64.5%. Such differences of pollution risk assessment indicated that the contents of the same heavy metal were inconsistent in soil and crops. Our results further showed that the heavy metals in soil had the greatest influence on Zn in crops. Pb and Cr in soil had synergistic effects on the crop absorption of Zn, whereas As, Hg and Cu played antagonistic roles in the crop absorption of Zn. Our study confirms that heavy metals in soil would variously influence heavy metals in crops and the interaction of heavy metals is very important for pollution risk control, which have been largely ignored yet.</p>
environmental sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper primarily aims to address the following issues: 1. **Risk Differences Between Soil Heavy Metal Pollution and Crop Heavy Metal Pollution**: The study compares and analyzes the potential ecological risk (ERI) of heavy metals (such as Cadmium Cd, Mercury Hg, etc.) in soil and the human health risk (HRI) of heavy metals (such as Arsenic As, etc.) in crops, exploring the risk differences between the two. 2. **Relationship Between Heavy Metal Content in Soil and Crops**: It investigates how heavy metals in soil affect the accumulation of heavy metals in crops and the interactions between different heavy metals within the soil-crop system. Specifically, the paper addresses these issues through the following aspects: - **Study Area**: The industrial city of Ningbo in southeastern China was selected as a case study area, and data from 1815 pairs of soil and crop samples were collected. - **Risk Assessment**: - Potential Ecological Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Soil: The ecological risk index (ERI) is used to analyze the pollution levels of heavy metals in soil and their potential ecological risks. - Human Health Risk Assessment of Heavy Metals in Crops: The health risk index (HRI) is used to evaluate the impact of heavy metal intake through food on human health. - **Spatial Variability Analysis**: The geographical detector method is used to analyze the spatial variability of potential ecological risks and human health risks. - **Heavy Metal Risk Classification**: Different risk levels (low, medium, and high) are classified based on various risk index values, and corresponding management measures are proposed. - **Correlation Analysis of Heavy Metal Content in Soil and Crops**: - Partial correlation analysis is used to explore the relationship between a specific heavy metal in soil and its content in crops, excluding the influence of other variables. - Stepwise linear regression analysis is used to investigate the linear relationship between heavy metal content in crops and multiple heavy metal contents in soil. Through the above research, the paper reveals the characteristics and differences of heavy metal pollution risks in the soil-crop system and emphasizes the importance of the complex interactions between soil heavy metals and crop heavy metals for pollution risk control.