Abstract:The assessment of fragility of underground civil defense structures is of paramount importance in ensuring their functionality and enhancing safety in seismic-prone regions. This study aims to explore the evolution law of seismic fragility for a shallowly buried large-section underground civil defense structure in soft soils, employing advanced data-based approaches. To achieve this, a two-dimensional (2D) nonlinear finite element model of the soil-civil defense structure interaction system was established, integrating data-based parameters and insights. Subsequently, the cloud and incremental dynamical analysis (IDA) methods were employed to develop a probabilistic seismic demand model for the shallowly buried large-section civil defense structure, effectively utilizing data-based approaches to account for the nonlinear characteristics of the soil and the uncertainties of input seismic motions. Based on this model, seismic fragility curves were generated using different seismic intensity measures (IMs), and the evaluation of IMs was carried out by the efficiency and practicality analyses of IMs. These curves were then systematically compared with other existing empirical and analytical fragility curves. The developed fragility curves were subsequently applied to assess seismic risk and resilience for a typical underground civil defense structure in soft soils, offering valuable data-driven insights into the structure's performance under various scenarios. The results indicated that the seismic fragility of the civil defense structure increases with the softening of the soil. Moreover, this study highlighted the substantial influence of structural typologies and local soil conditions on the fragility of civil defense structures, particularly the seismic fragility of underground structures characterized by shallowly buried and large-section, and demonstrating the utility of data-based approaches in comprehending complex interactions. The efficiency and practicality analyses highlighted that ground surface IMs outperform bedrock IMs and acceleration-type IMs over velocity-type IMs. The proposed seismic fragility curves indicated that the exceedance probability for each damage state gradually approaches 100% with the increase of seismic intensity. Finally, a case study was presented on the use of seismic fragility curves to assessment of seismic risk and seismic resilience of civil defense structure. The outcomes of this research, enriched by data-based approaches, can serve as invaluable references for seismic performance assessment, risk analysis, and resilience evaluation of typical civil defense structures in similar soft soil sites.

Data‐driven machine learning for multi‐hazard fragility surfaces in seismic resilience analysis

Machine Learning-based Seismic Fragility Curves for RC Bridge Piers

Methodology to generate earthquake-tsunami fragility surfaces for community resilience modeling

Multivariable fragility surfaces for earthquake-induced damage assessment of buildings integrating structural features

Multi-Hazard Resilience Assessment of a Coastal Community Due to Offshore Earthquakes

Seismic Fragility Estimation Through Real-Time Hybrid Simulation and Surrogate-Based Multi-Fidelity Monte Carlo Predictor

Seismic fragility analysis of slopes based on large-scale shaking table model tests

Integrating Real‐time Hybrid Simulation with Multi‐fidelity Monte Carlo Predictor for Seismic Fragility Assessment

Toward multivariate fragility functions for seismic damage and loss estimation of high‐rise buildings

Physics-Guided Machine Learning for Structural Metamodeling and Fragility Analysis

Hurricane Surge-Wave Building Fragility Methodology for Use in Damage, Loss, and Resilience Analysis

Seismic fragility analysis of structures via an Adaptive Gaussian Mixture Model and its application to resilience assessment

Seismic Risk Evaluation by Fragility Curves Using Metamodel Methods

Physics-informed Machine Learning Framework for Seismic Fragility Analysis of Steel Structures

Efficient seismic fragility analysis method utilizing ground motion clustering and probabilistic machine learning

Bayesian tsunami fragility modeling considering input data uncertainty

An Unsupervised Machine Learning Based Ground Motion Selection Method for Computationally Efficient Estimation of Seismic Fragility

Efficient Seismic Fragility Analysis of Structures from Dynamic Reliability Perspective

Fragility modeling practices and their implications on risk and resilience analysis: From the structure to the network scale

Seismic fragility and resilience assessment of shallowly buried large-section underground civil defense structure in soft soils: Framework and application

Hierarchical and Mixed Uncertainty Quantification for Simulation-Based Structural Seismic Fragility Analysis