Abstract:In their seminal experiment in 1944, Heider and Simmel revealed that humans have a pronounced tendency to impose narrative meaning even in the presence of simple animations of geometric shapes. Despite the shapes having no discernible features or emotions, participants attributed strong social context, meaningful interactions, and even emotions to them. This experiment, run on traditional 2D displays has since had a significant impact on fields ranging from psychology to narrative storytelling. Virtual Reality (VR), on the other hand, offers a significantly new viewing paradigm, a fundamentally different type of experience with the potential to enhance presence, engagement and immersion. In this work, we explore and analyze to what extent the findings of the original experiment by Heider and Simmel carry over into a VR setting. We replicate such experiment in both traditional 2D displays and with a head mounted display (HMD) in VR, and use both subjective (questionnaire-based) and objective (eye-tracking) metrics to record the observers' visual behavior. We perform a thorough analysis of this data, and propose novel metrics for assessing the observers' visual behavior. Our questionnaire-based results suggest that participants who viewed the animation through a VR headset developed stronger emotional connections with the geometric shapes than those who viewed it on a traditional 2D screen. Additionally, the analysis of our eye-tracking data indicates that participants who watched the animation in VR exhibited fewer shifts in gaze, suggesting greater engagement with the action. However, we did not find evidence of differences in how subjects perceived the roles of the shapes, with both groups interpreting the animation's plot at the same level of accuracy. Our findings may have important implications for future psychological research using VR, especially regarding our understanding of social cognition and emotions.

Would you rather come to a tango concert in theater or in VR? Aesthetic emotions & social presence in musical experiences, either live, 2D or 3D

The sentiment of a virtual rock concert

Concert experiences in virtual reality environments

Real vs. immersive-virtual emotional experience: Analysis of psycho-physiological patterns in a free exploration of an art museum

A Study on the Application of Multi-sensory Interaction Technology in Enhancing Concert Audience Immersion

When sound modulates vision: VR applications for art and entertainment

Immersive-360° theater: User experience in the virtual auditorium and platform efficacy for current and underserved audiences.

How Does Visual Context of Urban Open Spaces Drive Soundscape Pleasantness and Eventfulness: a Laboratory Experiment Using a Higher Order Ambisonics Speaker System and Immersive Virtual Reality

Investigating how immersive virtual reality and active navigation mediate the experience of virtual concerts

Designing and Evaluating a VR Lobby for a Socially Enriching Remote Opera Watching Experience

Neurophysiological correlates of embodiment and motivational factors during the perception of virtual architectural environments

Audience Experiences of a Volumetric Virtual Reality Music Video

Designing an augmented experience for a music archive: What does the audience need beyond the sense of hearing?

What Is the Relationship Among Positive Emotions, Sense of Presence, and Ease of Interaction in Virtual Reality Systems? An On-Site Evaluation of a Commercial Virtual Experience

Emotional Qualities of VR Space

Interactive Virtual Reality Orchestral Music.

Enhancing Well-Being: A Comparative Study of Virtual Reality Chromotherapy Rooms with Static, Dynamic, and Empty Environments

Revisiting the Heider and Simmel experiment for social meaning attribution in virtual reality

Immersed in Art: The Impact of Affinity for Technology Interaction and Hedonic Motivation on Aesthetic Experiences in Virtual Reality

Direct comparison of virtual reality and 2D delivery on sense of presence, emotional and physiological outcome measures

The virtual drum circle: polyrhythmic music interactions in extended reality