Life cycle water footprint comparison of biomass-to-hydrogen and coal-to-hydrogen processes

Peizhe Cui,Dong Yao,Zhaoyuan Ma,Yuanyuan Shen,Xingyi Liu,Kexu Li,Zhaoyou Zhu,Zhiqiang Liu,Jun Gao,Yinglong Wang,Sheng Yang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2021.145056

2021-06-01

Abstract:<p>Water is essential for the industrial production of hydrogen. This study investigates the production of hydrogen from biomass and coal. To date, there are few studies focusing on the water footprint of biomass-to-hydrogen and coal-to-hydrogen processes. This research conducted a life cycle water use analysis on wheat straw biomass and coal to hydrogen via pyrolysis gasification processes. The results show that the water consumption of the entire biomass-to-hydrogen process was 76.77 L/MJ, of which biomass cultivation was the dominant contributor (99%). Conversely, the water consumption of the coal-to-hydrogen process was only 1.06 L/MJ, wherein the coal production stage accounted for only 4.15% for the total water consumption, which is far lower than that of the biomass-to-hydrogen process. The hydrogen production stage of biomass hydrogen production accounted for 76% of the total water consumption when excluding the water consumption of straw growth, whereas that of the coal hydrogen production stage was 96%. This research provides the associated water consumption, within a specified boundary, of both hydrogen production processes, and the influence of major factors on total water consumption was demonstrated using sensitivity analysis.</p>

environmental sciences

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper primarily explores the water footprint issues in the Biomass-to-Hydrogen (BTH) and Coal-to-Hydrogen (CTH) processes and conducts a life cycle water use analysis.

### Research Objectives

The paper aims to study the water consumption in the hydrogen production processes from biomass and coal, in order to provide guidance for the effective utilization and management of water resources. Currently, there is limited research on the water footprint of biomass-to-hydrogen and coal-to-hydrogen processes, thus this study fills a gap in this field.

### Main Findings

- **Biomass-to-Hydrogen**: The total water consumption for the biomass-to-hydrogen process is 76.77 liters per megajoule (MJ), with the biomass cultivation stage being the main contributor (accounting for 99%).
- **Coal-to-Hydrogen**: In contrast, the water consumption for the coal-to-hydrogen process is only 1.06 liters per megajoule, which is significantly lower than that of the biomass-to-hydrogen process. In the coal-to-hydrogen process, the production stage accounts for 96% of the total water consumption.

### Other Important Points

- The paper also analyzes the main factors affecting total water consumption and proposes constructive measures to improve water resource wastage.
- For biomass-to-hydrogen, excluding the water consumption during the straw growth process, the water footprint of the hydrogen production stage accounts for 76% of the total water footprint.
- When using coal as a raw material, the hydrogen production stage accounts for 96% of the total water footprint.
- The entire study uses Monte Carlo simulation to analyze the uncertainty of input factors and determine the impact of this uncertainty on the results.

### Conclusion

By comparing the water consumption in the biomass-to-hydrogen and coal-to-hydrogen processes, the paper reveals the different water resource demands of various hydrogen production methods and provides important reference information for future energy planning, especially when considering water resource constraints.