Can Casual Game-Design Strategies be Applied to Educational Games

Thomas P. Buijtenweg

Abstract:In this essay I will discuss which casual game design strategies should not be applied to educational games and why. I will be looking at A Casual Revolution in order to determine a proper definition and address Huizinga's “play” in regard to educational games and their effectiveness depending on target audience requirements.

Computer Science,Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Cognitive behavioral game design: a unified model for designing serious games

Katryna Starks

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00028

2014-02-03

Abstract:Video games have a unique ability to engage, challenge, and motivate, which has led teachers, psychology specialists, political activists and health educators to find ways of using them to help people learn, grow and change. Serious games, as they are called, are defined as games that have a primary purpose other than entertainment. However, it is challenging to create games that both educate and entertain. While game designers have embraced some psychological concepts such as flow and mastery, understanding how these concepts work together within established psychological theory would assist them in creating effective serious games. Similarly, game design professionals have understood the propensity of video games to teach while lamenting that educators do not understand how to incorporate educational principles into game play in a way that preserves the entertainment. Bandura (2006) social cognitive theory (SCT) has been used successfully to create video games that create positive behavior outcomes, and teachers have successfully used Gardner's (1983) theory of multiple intelligences (MIs) to create engaging, immersive learning experiences. Cognitive behavioral game design is a new framework that incorporates SCT and MI with game design principles to create a game design blueprint for serious games.
Casual Games Before Casual Games: Historicizing Paper Puzzle Games in an Era of Digital Play

Mark R. Johnson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/1555412018790423

IF: 2.18

2018-08-01

Games and Culture

Abstract:This article examines “paper puzzle games”—crosswords, Sudoku, Kakuro, word searches, and so forth—in order to historicize and contextualize “casual games,” complicate our notions of “casual” play, and open up paper puzzle games to game studies consideration for the first time. The article begins by identifying the dearth of literature on paper puzzle games and offers an initial examination of these games through the lens of casual games, play, and players. It focuses on six traits in casual game design: appealing themes, ease of access, ease of learning, minimal required expertise, fast rewards, and temporal flexibility. It demonstrates that—from a perspective of mechanics, demographics, and contexts of play—paper puzzle games are excellent examples of casual games and therefore important to fully study. It also shows the complexity of paper puzzles as a topic in their own right, opening them up for future examination.

communication,cultural studies
From Content to Context: Videogames as Designed Experience

Kurt Squire

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189x035008019

2006-11-01

Educational Researcher

Abstract:Interactive immersive entertainment, or videogame playing, has emerged as a major entertainment and educational medium. As research and development initiatives proliferate, educational researchers might benefit by developing more grounded theories about them. This article argues for framing game play as a designed experience. Players’ understandings are developed through cycles of performance within the gameworlds, which instantiate particular theories of the world (ideological worlds). Players develop new identities both through game play and through the gaming communities in which these identities are enacted. Thus research that examines game-based learning needs to account for both kinds of interactions within the game-world and in broader social contexts. Examples from curriculum developed for Civilization III and Supercharged! show how games can communicate powerful ideas and open new identity trajectories for learners.

education & educational research
Foundations of Game-Based Learning

Jan L. Plass,Bruce D. Homer,Charles K. Kinzer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2015.1122533

2015-10-02

Educational Psychologist

Abstract:In this article we argue that to study or apply games as learning environments, multiple perspectives have to be taken into account. We first define game-based learning and gamification, and then discuss theoretical models that describe learning with games, arguing that playfulness is orthogonal to learning theory. We then review design elements of games that facilitate learning by fostering learners' cognitive, behavioral, affective, and sociocultural engagement with the subject matter. Finally, we discuss the basis of these design elements in cognitive, motivational, affective, and sociocultural foundations by reviewing key theories from education and psychology that are the most pertinent to game-based learning and by describing empirical research on learning with games that has been or should be conducted. We conclude that a combination of cognitive, motivational, affective, and sociocultural perspectives is necessary for both game design and game research to fully capture what games have to offer for learning.

education & educational research,psychology, educational
Games, Learning and Engagement: What Teachers might learn from Games Designers

Simon Grey

DOI: https://doi.org/10.29311/ndtps.v0i11.576

2016-12-16

New Directions in the Teaching of Physical Sciences

Abstract:This paper explores the role of games in learning. Beginning with some carefully selected definitions of games, comparisons are drawn between the fields of games design and of learning and teaching, highlighting a parallel between games as designed experiences, and teaching as designed learning experiences. Games are seen as being highly engaging, which has led to a rise in the fields of Game Based Learning and Gamification. Ultimately when designing games, game based learning, gamified experiences or learning experiences engagement is a key factor. This leads to the study of human psychology and motivation including concepts of extrinsic versus intrinsic motivation (Pink, 2011), self-determination theory (Rigby & Ryan, 2010) and flow (Csikszentmihalyi, 1990).Keywords: Engagement, Motivation, Game Design
Gamification Design in Education

Gil Moutinho,Isabel Azevedo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-5021-2.ch002

2021-01-01

Abstract:Gamification consists of the usage of game elements in non-entertainment applications to improve the motivation and results of their users. Guidelines can prevent the problem of poor gamification design and, in the world of education, be used in gamified educational systems to help students finish their courses. Some popular gamification design frameworks were studied, leading to the creation of a set of five guidelines that bring together their strengths while addressing their weaknesses. These guidelines were used for the development of a Moodle course aimed at college students, along with a plugin called “Gamification Banner.” This environment was evaluated by a group of volunteers, and it was found that students favor gamification, although it was not possible to prove that their grades are positively influenced given the short time of the tests.
What Should Be the Role of Computer Games in Education?

Richard E. Mayer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2372732215621311

2016-01-12

Policy Insights from the Behavioral and Brain Sciences

Abstract:Game advocates call for replacing conventional schooling with educational activities based on computer games. These claims were examined by reviewing published research on games for learning and then drawing policy implications. Value-added research shows that the most promising features of games use conversational language, put words in spoken form, add prompts to explain, add advice or explanations, and add relevant pregame activities. Cognitive consequences research shows that first-person shooter games improve perceptual attention skills. Media comparison research shows that games are more effective than conventional media for science learning. However, an educational revolution based on gaming is not indicated. Policy implications are to use games for targeted learning objectives, align games with classroom activities, avoid confusing liking with learning, and use games to adapt activities to maintain challenge. Research evidence informs decisions about educational games.
Finding Dark Patterns in Casual Mobile Games Using Heuristic Evaluation

Refal Pradama Dahlan,Meredita Susanty

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33322/petir.v15i2.1151

2022-11-28

Petir

Abstract:The popularity and monetary success of casual games are owed to many factors, but some of them that are not entirely honest and ethical. One of them comes in the form of the implementation of a dark pattern, a design pattern that negatively affects the experience of playing the game they are implemented. This research unveils the dark patterns most commonly used in popular and profitable casual mobile games, using heuristic evaluation conducted by five undergraduate student evaluators that have sufficient domain knowledge and experience of the topic at hand. Three of those dark patterns are (1) Pay to Skip:When the game sells various game elements that allow the players to skip some of its core challenges, (2) Grinding: When the game forces the players to sit through repetitive mechanics to make progress in the game, and (3) Playing by Appointment; When the game forces the player to play it during a specific time,through the use of rewards or punishments. The findings of this research should act as a counter-guideline on developing a casual game, as well as and provide the basis on future discussions on ethical game design.
How Digital Strategy and Management Games Can Facilitate the Practice of Dynamic Decision-Making

André Czauderna,Alexandra Budke

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/educsci10040099

2020-04-08

Education Sciences

Abstract:This paper examines how digital strategy and management games that have been initially designed for entertainment can facilitate the practice of dynamic decision-making. Based on a comparative qualitative analysis of 17 games—organized into categories derived from a conceptual model of decision-making design—this article illustrates two ways in which these games may be useful in supporting the learning of dynamic decision-making in educational practice: (1) Players must take over the role of a decider and solve situations in which players must pursue different conflicting goals by making a continuous series of decisions on a variety of actions and measures; (2) three of the features of the games are considered to structure players’ practice of decision-making and foster processes of learning through the curation of possible decisions, the offering of lucid feedback and the modification of time. This article also highlights the games’ shortcomings, from an educational perspective, as players’ decisions are restricted by the numbers of choices they can make within the game, and certain choices are rewarded more than others. An educational application of the games must, therefore, entail a critical reflection of players’ limited choices inside a necessarily biased system.
Using games in geographical and planning-related teaching: Serious games, edutainment, board games and role-play

Guy M. Robinson,Michael Hardman,Robert J. Matley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssaho.2021.100208

2021-01-01

Abstract:This paper reviews the use of games in geographical teaching, including prior to the emergence of computer-based (digital) games. The growing popularity of ‘serious games’ and ‘edutainment’ is addressed, focusing on their perceived advantages in classroom-based teaching. The blurring between digital games for educational purposes and games primarily for entertainment is discussed, reflecting on the popularity of SimCity and the potential of these games for learning about urban planning. This analysis champions games enabling students to play different roles and produce realistic ‘real life’ outcomes. Two examples of non-digital board games, Participology and Geogopoly, illustrate how role play broadens students' understanding of planning and human geography.
Academic Game Design Education: A Comparative Perspective

André Czauderna

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-02762-9_2

2018-01-01

Abstract:This paper outlines a model of game design education that considers not only the creative and technological design and development of digital games, but also their broader aesthetic, historical and cultural contexts and implications. The model is derived from a comparative analysis of several undergraduate programs in Australia, Germany, Great Britain and the United States which was presented by the author at JCSG 2018.
Educational game design: game elements for promoting engagement

Angela He

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1709.09931

IF: 6.4588

2017-09-27

Human-Computer Interaction

Abstract:Engagement in educational games, a recently popular academic topic, has been shown to increase learning performance, as well as a number of attitudinal factors, such as intrinsic interest and motivation. However, there is a lack of research on how games can be designed to promote engagement. This mixed methods case study aimed to discover effective game elements for promoting 17-18 year old high school students' engagement with an educational game. Using within-case and cross-case analyses and triangulated data, 10 elements emerged and were categorized into the constructs of story, gameplay, and atmosphere. Examples and connections to the literature for each element are reported. Findings implicate that educational game design for both learning and engagement is composed of educational-game specific elements, game design for solely engagement is similar for both educational and entertainment games, and a gap on educational game design technique instead of theory should be addressed to further benefit educational game development.
Toward Understanding the Potential of Games for Learning: Learning Theory, Game Design Characteristics, and Situating Video Games in Classrooms

Selen Turkay,Daniel Hoffman,Charles K. Kinzer,Pantiphar Chantes,Christopher Vicari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/07380569.2014.890879

2014-04-03

Computers in the Schools

Abstract:Researchers have argued that an effort should be made to raise teachers’ and parents’ awareness of the potentially positive educational benefits of playing video games (e.g., see Baek, 2008). One part of this effort should be to increase understanding of how video games can be situated within teachers’ existing goals and knowledge of learning and instruction. However, relatively little research on game-based learning addresses teachers (Ketelhut & Schifter, 2011), and for many a gap remains between the apparent enthusiasm of researchers and policy makers relative to the potential of educational games and the attendant practicalities of selecting and implementing video games in classroom settings. This article begins to bridge this gap by providing research-based areas of awareness and a discussion of factors that can facilitate understanding related to choosing and using video games. To this end, we show how educational games can be conceptualized from different theoretical perspectives on learning and discuss a number of essential design issues that educators should take into account when considering a video game for educational use.
Gamification for educational purposes: What are the factors contributing to varied effectiveness?

Zhanni Luo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10639-021-10642-9

2021-07-01

Education and Information Technologies

Abstract:Gamification refers to the use of game-design elements or mechanisms in non-game contexts to promote the expected behaviours. Though theoretically promising, empirical studies reported mixed results as to the effectiveness of gamification in educational practices. To understand this issue better, this author selected 44 articles on the topic of educational gamification with the use of a bibliometric analysis software <i>HistCite</i>, followed by a descriptive content analysis on these articles. This author examined three issues, including how effective the educational gamification implementations were in previous empirical studies, how the effectiveness has been measured, and what factors contribute to varied effectiveness results. One significant output of the current study is the redefinition of two terms: game elements refer to "the obvious game-like elements that are frequently used in digital games or gamification, which are concrete nouns", and gamification mechanisms refer to "the underlying guidelines that make gamification activities engaging, which are abstract nouns that relate to humans' innate psychological needs". What's more, the content analysis helped summarise a framework describing what makes gamification engaging, which contains goal, visualisation, immediate feedback, adaptation, challenge, competition, reward, and fun failure. Limitations and suggestions for future studies have been discussed.

education & educational research
Values And Design Strategies Of Emotional Design In Educational Games

Mingze Yuan,Junjie Shang

2018-01-01

Abstract:With the educational value of games being more and more recognized, educational games are stepping into a new stage of rapid development. However, although the amount of educational games is rising fast, only a few can integrate well with both learning and gaming. Therefore, how to design educational games is becoming an important subject. This paper attempts to introduce an emotional approach to educational games design. First, the paper has a brief review of emotional design. Then the paper points out its values for educational games. Lastly, the paper puts forward a strategy framework which is composed of four parts: aesthetic design, flow design, social design and content design.
Teacher-Designed Games

Yang Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-7998-4739-7.ch008

2021-01-01

Abstract:Video games play an important role in education; however, the idea of teachers as designers of digital classroom games to support student learning has not been widely embraced. The purpose of this study was to gain a deeper understanding of why and how teachers used and designed games in teaching differently with various gaming background. This mixed-method case study involved a group of teachers who used and/or designed games for students. The four unique case groups were grounded in three regions and four school districts in Alberta, Canada. First and second cycle data coding and analyses were used to answer 1) what factors influenced the types of games teachers used and designed in teaching and 2) what factors influenced how and why teachers integrated game-based learning in teaching.
Playful Education and Innovative Gamified Learning Approaches

George P. Pavlidis,Stella Markantonatou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/978-1-6684-3710-0.ch009

2022-01-01

Abstract:In the recent decades, there has been a significant investment in the incorporation of games in the educational practice. This has taken either the form of game-based learning or serious gaming. A literature review on gaming and education results in numerous works tackling different aspects of the approach. Even a simple search on the Web on gaming and learning produces multi-million results. In this work, we try to touch not only the surface of this approach and provide typical game-based learning evaluation results but also to explore its inner workings (offering a modest mixed philosophical and science aspect) and to provide an even more concrete foundation for a playful education.
A Curriculum Design to Cultivate Creative Thinking Through Educational Games.

Sijie Ma,Junjie Shang,Haiming Xiao

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-59360-9_40

2017-01-01

Abstract:As creativity is important for innovation and future success in the global competition, the cultivation of students' creative thinking has been a heated research topic in the field of education. Educational games can effectively support teaching and learning in many ways, and this paper presents a curriculum design with game-based learning. On the basis of this curriculum, the topic of balance between education and entertainment in gamed-based learning curriculum design, and the six principles on curriculum design for cultivating creative thinking through educational games have been discussed.
Gamification in Mobile Application Development Education

Yuchen Gui,Fan Zhao,Eugene Hoyt

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-22602-2_30

2019-01-01

Abstract:Compared to traditional lecture education pedagogy, gamification is positioned to offer several advantages for motivating and engaging students. In this paper, we aimed to assess previous studies of gamification applications in education to identify key factors and challenges influencing the effectiveness of gamification. We reviewed both success cases and failure cases with gamification applications in education. To improve the usefulness of gamification in education, we recommend the alignment of gamified functions and non-game context in gamification design. A gamification model was proposed to improve students’ learning outcomes in a mobile application class.
Harnessing Computer Games in Education

Morris S. Y. Jong,Junjie Shang,Fong-Lok Lee,Jimmy H. M. Lee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4018/jdet.2008010101

2008-01-01

International Journal of Distance Education Technologies

Abstract:Besides the ability of making learning more interesting, educators and researchers have been exploring other pedagogical potentials of computer games. How to employ games for constructivist learning and teaching has become an attention in the field of education and game design in recent years. This article gives an introduction to game-based learning. On top of discussing games’ intrinsic educational traits from the motivational, cognitive and socio-cultural perspectives, we also review two recent foci of game-based learning. The first one is “education in games” which is an approach for adopting existing commercial games for educational use. The second is “games in education” in which the games are designed specifically with underlying pedagogy for some curricula.

Can Casual Game-Design Strategies be Applied to Educational Games

Cognitive behavioral game design: a unified model for designing serious games

Casual Games Before Casual Games: Historicizing Paper Puzzle Games in an Era of Digital Play

From Content to Context: Videogames as Designed Experience

Foundations of Game-Based Learning

Games, Learning and Engagement: What Teachers might learn from Games Designers

Gamification Design in Education

What Should Be the Role of Computer Games in Education?

Finding Dark Patterns in Casual Mobile Games Using Heuristic Evaluation

How Digital Strategy and Management Games Can Facilitate the Practice of Dynamic Decision-Making

Using games in geographical and planning-related teaching: Serious games, edutainment, board games and role-play

Academic Game Design Education: A Comparative Perspective

Educational game design: game elements for promoting engagement

Toward Understanding the Potential of Games for Learning: Learning Theory, Game Design Characteristics, and Situating Video Games in Classrooms

Gamification for educational purposes: What are the factors contributing to varied effectiveness?

Values And Design Strategies Of Emotional Design In Educational Games

Teacher-Designed Games

Playful Education and Innovative Gamified Learning Approaches

A Curriculum Design to Cultivate Creative Thinking Through Educational Games.

Gamification in Mobile Application Development Education

Harnessing Computer Games in Education