Abstract:Background: Chromatographic peakpicking continues to represent a significant bottleneck in automated LC-MS workflows. Uncontrolled false discovery rates and the lack of manually-calibrated quality metrics require researchers to visually evaluate individual peaks, requiring large amounts of time and breaking replicability. This problem is exacerbated in noisy environmental datasets and for novel separation methods such as hydrophilic interaction columns in metabolomics, creating a demand for a simple, intuitive, and robust metric of peak quality. Results: Here, we manually labeled four HILIC oceanographic particulate metabolite datasets to assess the performance of individual peak quality metrics. We used these datasets to construct a predictive model calibrated to the likelihood that visual inspection by an MS expert would include a given mass feature in the downstream analysis. We implemented two novel peak quality metrics, a custom signal-to-noise metric and a test of similarity to a bell curve, both calculated from the raw data in the extracted ion chromatogram, and found that these outperformed existing measurements of peak quality. A simple logistic regression model built on two metrics reduced the fraction of false positives in the analysis from 70-80% down to 1-5% and showed minimal overfitting when applied to novel datasets. We then explored the implications of this quality thresholding on the conclusions obtained by the downstream analysis and found that while only 10% of the variance in the dataset could be explained by depth in the default output from the peakpicker, approximately 40% of the variance was explained when restricted to high-quality peaks alone. Conclusions: We conclude that the poor performance of peakpicking algorithms significantly reduces the power of both univariate and multivariate statistical analyses to detect environmental differences. We demonstrate that simple models built on intuitive metrics and derived from the raw data are more robust and can outperform more complex models when applied to new data. Finally, we show that in properly curated datasets, depth is a major driver of variability in the marine microbial metabolome and identify several interesting metabolite trends for future investigation.

qPeaks: A Linear Regression-Based Asymmetric Peak Model for Parameter-Free Automatized Detection and Characterization of Chromatographic Peaks in Non-Target Screening Data

Automating LC-MS/MS mass chromatogram quantification. Wavelet transform based peak detection and automated estimation of peak boundaries and signal-to-noise ratio using signal processing methods

A Simple Multi-Scale Gaussian Smoothing-Based Strategy for Automatic Chromatographic Peak Extraction

PeakBot: machine-learning-based chromatographic peak picking

PeakQC: A Software Tool for Omics-Agnostic Automated Quality Control of Mass Spectrometry Data

Automatic Peak Detection Algorithm Based on Continuous Wavelet Transform for Complex Chromatograms from Multi-detector Micro-scale Gas Chromatographs

Picky with peakpicking: assessing chromatographic peak quality with simple metrics in metabolomics

Chemometric Strategy for Automatic Chromatographic Peak Detection and Background Drift Correction in Chromatographic Data.

Retention Time Trajectory Matching for Peak Identification in Chromatographic Analysis

PeakPerformance - a tool for Bayesian inference-based fitting of LC-MS/MS peaks

PeakClimber: A software tool for the accurate quantification of complex multianalyte HPLC chromatograms using the exponential Gaussian function

Mechanistic Understanding of the Discrepancies between Common Peak Picking Algorithms in Liquid Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry-Based Metabolomics

Systematic Evaluation of Chromatographic Peak Quality for Targeted Mass Spectrometry via Variational Autoencoder

Bayesian Peak Detection for Pro-TOF MS MALDI Data

From untargeted chemical profiling to peak tables – A fully automated AI driven approach to untargeted GC-MS

REALISATION OF A CHROMATOGRAPHIC PEAK RECOGNITION ALGORITHM

ICPD-A New Peak Detection Algorithm for LC/MS

Algorithm for Automatic Peak Detection and Quantification for GC-IMS Spectra

Handling of problematic ion chromatograms with the Automated Target Screening (ATS) workflow for unsupervised analysis of high-resolution mass spectrometry data

Automated 2D peak detection in gas chromatography-ion mobility spectrometry through persistent homology

Stronger findings from mass spectral data through multi-peak modeling