An Empirical Evaluation of a New Heuristic Method for Identifying Safety Improvement Sites on Rural Highways: An Oregon Case Study

Bishal Dhakal,Ahmed Al-Kaisy

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16052047

IF: 3.9

2024-03-02

Sustainability

Abstract:Road safety is considered one of the fundamental factors for sustainable mobility, which requires establishing effective highway safety management programs and processes. Identifying safety improvement sites (network screening) is a critical step in the state roadway safety programs. The overall effectiveness of these programs largely relies on the robustness of the network screening method in identifying sites with high potential for safety improvements. This study investigates the network screening performance of a new proposed methodology that employs heuristic scoring schemes to account for roadway and roadside characteristics, crash history, and traffic exposure. The new method, originally proposed for use on rural low-volume roads, is simplistic in that it does not require exact and detailed information on traffic and geometric characteristics and can still be applied in the absence of crash data. The performance evaluation is conducted using a sample of 1495 miles of rural two-lane highway segments in Oregon. The effectiveness of the proposed method is assessed using observed crash history and compared to the well-established Empirical Bayes method as a reference. The effect of traffic level on the performance of the proposed method was evaluated using separate analyses for lower and higher traffic volume segments. The study findings indicate that the effectiveness of the proposed method in identifying sites with potential safety improvements is overall high and slightly exceeded that of the more sophisticated and data-intensive Empirical Bayes method. When data were stratified by traffic volume, the proposed method was found to be more effective for lower volume roads; however, the Empirical Bayes method outperformed the proposed method for higher volume roads.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problem does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to evaluate the performance of a new, simple road network screening method in identifying safety improvement points on rural roads. Specifically:

- **Research Background**: Road safety is one of the key factors for sustainable transportation. Effective highway safety management programs require the identification of segments with high safety improvement potential (i.e., network screening). Current methods often rely on detailed accident history data and traffic geometric feature data, which are difficult for local agencies managing rural low-traffic roads to achieve due to the lack of detailed data and professional technical background.

- **Research Objective**: A new network screening method is proposed, which is simple and does not require precise traffic and geometric characteristic data, and can even be applied in the absence of accident data. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of this method in practical applications and compare it with the widely used Empirical Bayes (EB) method.

- **Research Method**: The effectiveness of the new method was evaluated by analyzing a sample of approximately 1495 miles of rural two-lane road segments in Oregon. The applicability of the new method was further verified by comparing its performance with the EB method on segments with different traffic volumes.

- **Main Findings**: The results of the study indicate that the new method performs well overall in identifying potential safety improvement points, even slightly surpassing the more complex and data-intensive Empirical Bayes method. When stratified by traffic volume, the new method performs better on low-traffic roads but is not as effective as the Empirical Bayes method on high-traffic roads.

Overall, this paper aims to provide a simple and effective network screening method for rural road safety management to help improve road safety and reduce traffic accidents.