The Great War and the Use of Video Games as Historical and Educational Resources: A Conversation

Stefan Aguirre Quiroga,Iro Filippaki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.14198/raei.2018.31.13

2018-12-15

Revista Alicantina de Estudios Ingleses

Abstract:Iro Filippaki and Stefan Aguirre Quiroga exchange their views on the potentiality of video games as historical and educational resources in the study of the First World War.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Digital Cultures of Commemoration: Learning and Unlearning History through Video Games

Stefania Matei

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/cscs.2015.128

2015-05-01

Abstract:This paper is a reflection on how video games support representations of history by using the interactive particularities of the medium. History appears as a space that can be recreated through technologically-mediated performances in which players are assigned the role of participants in a story made available by design. Fiction and realism are constitutive parts of historical games in which players have no choice but to navigate a world depicted through precise programmes of action. By analysing a representative game in the historical genre (i.e. ‘Valiant Hearts: The Great War’), I argue that video games are tools prone to reshape the understanding of history in such a way that learning about past events becomes a matter of boundary control and collaborative knowledge production.
From pixels to pedagogy: using video games for higher education in the humanities

Jessica Van Horssen,Zoe Moreton,Gaspard Pelurson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.47408/jldhe.vi28.875

2023-09-24

Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education

Abstract:This paper explores how video games can enhance learning in the higher education Humanities classroom through play and critical discussions. Through the observation of two case studies, it aims to highlight important concepts and considerations and serve as a platform for future research and debate. The first case study utilised Sid Meier’s Civilization IV: Colonization (Firaxis Games, 2008) and involved first-year History students. They were encouraged to take part in critical assessment and discussion by pairing gameplay with lecture content featuring the same moments in history they experienced in the game. This led to the students being able to better challenge historical narratives through holistic reflexive engagement. The second case study used GreedFall (Spiders, 2019) to encourage students to question historical inaccuracies and utopian diversity. Through connecting gameplay to module outcomes, students unconsciously adopted a critical eye which indicates how the game can be used to debate race, Western imagination, and imperialism. We conclude that gaming in the classroom is an engaging way to deliver content and it enables students to develop critical and reflexive thinking within playful spaces. As such, this article focuses on the students studying the humanities and discusses the video game as a medium to identify and analyse ideologies, and gaming as a way of developing reflexive critical thinking and analytic skills.

English Else
The role of video games in obtaining and disseminating historical knowledge

О.М. Сапицька

DOI: https://doi.org/10.33216/1998-7927-2020-259-3-62-70

2020-02-18

ВІСНИК СХІДНОУКРАЇНСЬКОГО НАЦІОНАЛЬНОГО УНІВЕРСИТЕТУ імені Володимира Даля

Abstract:The formation of the historical background in video games is provided by spatial narratives. In recent years, they are more and more amenable to adjustments in the direction of maximally exact correspondence to socio-economic, political, cultural, domestic, geographical, climatic and so on elements of the localized on the scenario of the game`s chronotop. This may indicate another qualitative transformation of video games as a socio-technical and socio-cultural phenomenon, as well as about the positive cultural and intellectual dynamics of the modern “consumer society”. Computer video games, as part of the digital, educational and entertainment industry as a whole, are in a state of constant high-speed dynamic transformation in the context of global digitalization of all aspects of society and a lot of competition in the field of video games in particular. Based on the analytics of the results of direct surveys, statistical and factual data, in article an attempt was made to assess the use of video games as a non-formal education tool for relaying and consolidating historical knowledge for different age and social groups of game products consumers, as well as the appropriateness of their use in the classical educational system at different levels. Computer video games with the most accurate historical content as well as “alternative” historical content can become highly effective additional pedagogical tools for acquiring basic and in-depth knowledge of history both for self-education and in academic institutions. As part of the study of academic history, whole historical digital laboratories can be created that study both the multivariance of history and bring “alternative realities” into the linear real history of the development of human civilization. The success of using video games with historical content for the needs of academic history is high only if the teacher understands not only historical but also technical terms, knows the features of developmental psychology, knows the scenario and features of the video game proposed for modeling, and can develop their own teaching methods based on an interdisciplinary approach.
Gaming history: computer and video games as historical scholarship

Dawn Spring

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13642529.2014.973714

2014-11-06

Rethinking History

Abstract:‘Gaming History’ explores how scholarly computer and video games could be developed to present original historical scholarship and meet the standards of the discipline. Instead of a monograph and the presentation of the history as lineal narrative, the work of the historian could be produced as a video game. Not historical fiction that sacrifices history for story and not a video game that sacrifices history for gameplay, but a video game that presents original research rivaling any great work of history, transforming readers, learners, and viewers into players interacting with history. The video game offers far greater potential for the creation and presentation of history than any other entertainment or interactive media. Although computer and video games may seem to be far removed from the historical narrative, both examine and form points of view about how cultures, economies, polities, and societies function. Ignoring the realities of budget and hiring a game design team, this article will imagine how historical research could be presented as a scholarly game. To explore these issues, the article analyzes key game mechanics and narrative structure in the popular history-based video games: the Assassin's Creed series, the Total War series, Rockstar Games' L.A. Noire and Red Dead Redemption, and Paradox Interactive's Crusader Kings II and Europa Universalis. It also examines Tracy Fullerton's experimental game Walden. In addition, it explores how the game design process could be applied to developing a scholarly game.

history
Historical Video Games in the Context of Public History: Strategies for Reconstruction, Deconstruction and Politization of History

Dmitriy A. Belyaev,Ulyana P. Belyaeva

DOI: https://doi.org/10.46539/gmd.v4i1.204

2022-03-21

Abstract:Today, historical video games going beyond the boundaries of the purely entertainment framework of screen media are increasingly influencing the formation of the public history infosphere. The aim of the study is a comprehensive analysis of historical video games as a tool for constructing mass historical consciousness and the implementation of ideologized strategies for the politics of memory. Methodologically, the work is based on the concepts of “public history infosphere” and “politics of memory”, as well as the historical method and classification approach. In addition, elements of comparative analysis, the method of narrative research of cultural artifacts and the optics of I. Bogost’s procedural rhetoric are used. The study determines the specificity and nature of broadcasting historical plots in the context of procedural actualization of video game narratives. Starting from the interactive-procedural nature of video games, the original possibilities and objective constraints in the reproduction of “stories about the past” are revealed. It is demonstrated that the programmatic and subjective-user modalities of a video game existence endow it with rhizome and nomadic characteristics. Video game architectonics has an intention to deconstruct the “metaphysics of presence” and the main repressive instances characteristic of traditional historical narrative. At the same time, based on the concept of simulations by G. Frasca, three main formats of historical video game reconstructions are revealed: factual (plot and setting), logical-dynamic and hybrid. The article identifies the most common ways of distorting, mythologizing and politicizing history in video games. Special attention is paid to the explication of the ideologized concept of “anti-Sovietism” in video game plots, as a form of quasi-historical criticism of the Soviet regime and the continuation of the rhetoric of the “Cold War”. The results of the study can be used in the expert assessment of the space of public history, in the identification of relevant media tools and meaningful concepts that form its semantic framework. In addition, certain conclusions are essential for the effective correction of memory policy strategies implemented in screen digital media.
Video games as a screen-interactive platform of historical media education: educational potential and risks of politicization

Dmitriy A. Belyaev,Ulyana P. Belyaeva,,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.32744/pse.2021.4.32

2021-09-01

Perspectives of science and education

Abstract:Screen culture today, absorbing verbal-narrative and written culture, is the dominant memorial-representative format for the reproduction, preservation and broadcast of cultural information. Among the varieties of screen culture, since the beginning of the 21st century, video games have become especially popular and widespread. They possess unique interactive-procedural qualities, which, together with the traditional grammar of screen narrative, create an original complex of rhetorical techniques that effectively influence the mass public consciousness. In turn, the plot and visual design of video games is often based on historical narratives, becoming a platform for virtual interactive reconstruction of history. The study is devoted to the up-to-date topic of analyzing the on-screen phenomenon of video games as an innovative platform for historical media education, identifying its educational potential and the risks of political distortion of history. The methodological basis of the study is cultural-civilizational, dialectical and historical approaches, as well as structural-functional analysis, comparative-political science approach and systemic method. The study made it possible to identify a wide range of historical video games and classify the modalities of the implementation of historical topics in them with its general educational potential. In addition, the fundamental deconstructive nature of the actualization of the historical metanarrative in the procedural-interactive architectonics of video games has been determined. Finally, three main strategies for distorting and falsifying history in video games have been revealed. According to the results of the study, it was revealed that almost every significant cultural and historical era, with an emphasis on military battle plots, is reflected in the video game format. These game projects have serious educational potential, procedurally immersing the gamer in the context of the main historical facts, cultural aesthetics of the era and internal determinants of historical dynamics. At the same time, the postmodern essence of video games has been established, which poses a threat to the invariance of the perception of history, latently encouraging the intentions to rewrite it. Other risks are contained in the identified examples of politicization of the historical narrative of video games, which are concretized in the tendency to belittle the role of Russia in the international arena and the Eurocentric value accentuation.
Playing through to Europe? Depiction and Reception of the First World War in the Videogame Valiant Hearts

Jakub Šindelář

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/14782804.2022.2097206

2022-08-02

Journal of Contemporary European Studies

Abstract:The video game Valiant Hearts , released in 2014 for the First World War centenary, sold over 2.5 million copies and can be considered one of the major contemporary pop-culture historical representations of this war shaping public interpretations of this event. The paper explores how Valiant Hearts , as a kind of informal institution affecting historical remembrance, constructs and encourages a specific framing through the deployment of Europeanizing elements of anti-war narrative, Franco-German reconciliation narrative, and the de-nationalizing logic that indirectly legitimizes the European integration. The analysis of the videogame in the context of the historical film Merry Christmas (2005) is complemented with a close reading of illustrative empirical examples of Let's Plays (paratextual user-generated videos where people record themselves while playing videogames) that indicate how Europeans of different national backgrounds interact with the game Valiant Hearts . The examined cases point to how the everyday, seemingly apolitical leisure activity of playing and watching videogames dealing with history can advance Europeanizing narratives and present occasions for informal Europeanization.

area studies,political science,international relations
A future for game histories?

Alex Wade,Nick Webber

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311983.2016.1212635

2016-08-01

Cogent Arts and Humanities

Abstract:Recent years have seen an efflorescence of writing and curatorial work focused upon the past of video games. However, this work has tended to concentrate on particular forms of analysis, and privileged certain kinds of discourse. This article argues that these approaches limit our capacity to produce effective histories of and around games, and proposes more nuanced histories, informed by Foucauldian ideas of a genealogical approach to historical work, and a clear sense of the voices that present histories fail to represent. Broader, cultural game histories, we contend, offer us a clearer understanding of games’ past, and can move us away from the teleological, deterministic, and “great man” histories which dominate the present landscape. Reflecting on the past in this way also suggests an agenda for the future, in encouraging us to consider how and to what end we preserve video game culture.
Video Games in Education: Why They Should Be Used and How They Are Being Used

Leonard A. Annetta

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00405840802153940

2008-07-11

Theory Into Practice

Abstract:Today's K–20 students have been called, among other names, the net generation. As they matriculate through the education system, they are often exposed to materials and manipulatives used for the past 40 years, and not to the digital media to which they are accustomed. As student scores continue to regress from Grade 3 to Grade 12 and technical jobs once housed in the United States continue to be outsourced, it is critical to expose and challenge the Net Generation in environments that engage them and motivate them to explore, experiment, and construct their own knowledge. The commercial popularity of video games is beginning to transpose to the classroom; but is the classroom ready? Are teachers and administrators ready? This article provides a practical rationale for and experiences with integrating video games into the K–20 (kindergarten through graduate school) curriculum.

education & educational research
A Game Design Plot: Exploring the Educational Potential of History-Based Video Games

Farzan Baradaran Rahimi,Beaumie Kim,Richard M. Levy,Jeffrey E. Boyd

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1109/tg.2019.2954880

IF: 1.237

2020-09-01

IEEE Transactions on Games

Abstract:The number of video games that are developed based on real historical events and evidence is increasing. These history-based video games provide learning opportunities to players, but a certain type of such gamesfirst- and third-person shootershas not been carefully examined for their potentials. Knowing what players say about their game experienceeven if the information and knowledge are inaccuratehelps researchers understand what type of learning could happen with such games. In this article, we propose a systematic approach to assessing games as learning environments, using the method of comparing the authenticity of popular history-based video games. Through a qualitative data analysis, we studied players comments on the web-based communication services, such as game forums, digital distribution platforms, and discussion websites. Casual players conversations on these websites showed that there exist several learning potentials in the games for players, including building their understanding about history and historical forces of the time, through personally relating to specific events, social artifacts, and places.

computer science, artificial intelligence, software engineering
A Dissection of Video Games as a medium of Art: The Utilization of Aesthetics and the Effectiveness of Video Games as a Tool in Curriculum

Anthony Gilyard

Abstract:Over the years, video games have seen increasing acceptance as a classification of art by individuals other than those traditionally defined as gamers, such as politicians and educators. Art as defined by the Oxford English Dictionary has many definitions, but the definition discussed in this paper is “the expression or application of human creative skill and imagination, typically in a visual form” (“Art”). Once considered just a form of entertainment, video games have garnered much more cultural significance in society. The United States Supreme Court ruled in favor of the classification of video games as art in 2011, and even the French Minister of Culture, Renaud Donnedieu de Vabres, supported the recognition of video games as an art form in 2006. Despite being initially introduced as a form of entertainment, video games play an important role in popular culture as well as education. With the incorporation of aesthetics along with the capabilities of video games in the classroom, video games are a form of art that can be applied in several artistic disciplines. Video games, just like books, movies, or poetry, can be designed with various meanings, interpretations, or intent. For instance, what if video games are designed to integrate players into their gameplay, creating different experiences based off the interpretation of the player? In education, could students in a visual arts curriculum learn basic programming and how to create 2D art through a video game? Society in general can learn to appreciate and utilize video games beyond their current reach as they can

Education,Computer Science,Art
The interactive museum: Video games as history lessons through lore and affective design

Sky LaRell Anderson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2042753019834957

2019-03-07

Abstract:This article approaches games from the perspectives of design and analysis in order to describe how games might employ pedagogical strategies that capitalize on their strengths as interactive media while avoiding the pitfalls of traditional learning games. Specifically, it draws attention to how games employ world building through lore—such as through item text descriptions—as well as affective game design aesthetics to create a learning experience closer in similarity to touring a museum than reading a textbook. Describing this phenomenon as the interactive museum, the article discusses how the concept operates through an analysis of the game Valiant Hearts: The Great War. The article first addresses games as teaching tools, including their potential to teach about historical wars, while paying close attention to the ethical dilemma of producing an entertaining game that also aims to teach. The design analysis begins by examining item text descriptions, lore and historical world building before describing the affective aesthetic of the interactive museum. The article concludes with a discussion on games’ potential use of tangential learning as a method to teach through interactivity.

English Else
Gamified Automation in Immersive Media for Education and Research

Janelle Resch,Ireneusz,Ocelewski,Judy Ehrentraut,Michael Barnett-Cowan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1901.00729

2018-12-11

Physics Education

Abstract:The potential of using video games as well as gaming engines for educational and research purposes is promising, especially with the current progress of Industry 4.0 technologies such as augmented and virtual reality devices. However, it is important to be aware of the barriers of these technologies. Integrating additional software libraries into current developer environments would not only increase accessibility for the general public, but would gamify the development process through multiplayer functionality. In this paper we will briefly discuss a couple case studies demonstrating the usefulness of using Unreal Engine 4 for collaborative research purposes. In addition, we present several ideas on how to extend such development environments to further assist researchers and students to easily create prototypes for the purpose of gamified scientific creativity and inquiry.
The Underexplored Synergy: Cinema as an Ally to the World Wars

,Dharun Manikandan Srinivasan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54105/ijmcj.e1085.04010924

2024-09-30

Indian Journal of Mass Communication and Journalism

Abstract:This research explores the connection between The Great Wars and Cinema, examining how these major conflicts influenced and were influenced by the film industry. Beginning with an introduction to the causes and triggers of the wars, it traces the evolution of cinema from the pre-war era through the changes brought by the wars. The study focuses on the interdependent relationship between War and Cinema, highlighting how major participating countries used films for propaganda, morale-boosting, and ideological dissemination. As cinema became a dominant art form in the entertainment industry, it had significant socio-economic impacts, influencing national economies and public sentiment. The study also delves into the birth of "German Expressionism," a film technique that emerged in response to the societal trauma of the wars and significantly impacted modern cinema. This movement's distinct visual style and thematic depth continue to influence filmmakers even today. Additionally, the study examines the perspectives of civilians and soldiers on cinema during wartime periods, revealing how films served as both escapism and a reflection of reality. Through various case studies, the study illustrates cinema's role in shaping and reflecting the collective consciousness during these pivotal historical moments. This exploration offers valuable insights into how The Great Wars reshaped the landscape of cinema and left a lasting cultural legacy.
History-Themed Games in History Education: Experiences on a Blended World History Course

Mehmet Şükrü Kuran,Ahmet Erdem Tozoğlu,Cinzia Tavernari

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1805.00463

2018-04-26

Computers and Society

Abstract:In this paper we explain our experiences and observations on a blended world history course which combines classical lecture and discussion elements as well as video game sessions in which the students play strategy video games with heavy historical focus. The course, named Playing with The Past, is designed to experiment on how to integrate video games on teaching history especially in order to achieve a higher understanding of the contemporary social, political, economical, and technological context of a given era for a given nation. We ran the course four times between 2015 - 2018 with different video game titles having different historical models and observe the experiences and learning of students based on the quality of their written essays and articles. Our experiments and observations could be beneficial not only for the design of a general world history course, but also for a history course on specific periods, cultures, and nations.
Video games in the context of screen technoculture and media education: new rhetorical strategies and educational potential

Dmitriy A. Belyaev,,Ulyana P. Belyaeva,,,

DOI: https://doi.org/10.32744/pse.2021.6.2

2021-12-31

Perspectives of science and education

Abstract:Video games have become a prominent part of on-screen technoculture today, breaking the purely entertaining social labelling framework. They contribute to the generation of new social activities, and also become an innovative media space for the explication of artistic and aesthetic values, political meanings and educational practices. The aim of the study is the reconstruction and analysis of the cultural constitution of video games, revealing the features of their screen rhetorical capabilities, as well as revealing the educational potential of gamification practices and Digital Game Based Learning strategies. This is intended to form the competence-thematic framework of video games as a platform for modern media education. The methodological basis of the work is the cultural-historical and dialectical approaches, as well as the methods of systemic and structural-functional analysis. The study made it possible to trace the genesis of the cultural formation of video games, which demonstrated many strategies for their integration into the space of mass media culture. The main rhetorical models implemented in video games are analyzed. Particular attention is paid to the comprehensive consideration of procedural rhetoric as an original way of convincing the user through gameplay, interactive involvement in virtual practices. The foundations of the practice of gamification and the strategy of Digital Game Based Learning in education are considered. It identifies the possibilities of gamification as an innovative methodology for organizing incentives and rewards, and also identifies the range of difficulties and risks of total gamification of the educational process. Based on the results of the study, it was determined that video games use an original complex of rhetorical techniques that combine both traditional audiovisual formats of narrative, characteristic of other on-screen media, and procedural-interactive techniques. They made it possible to directly integrate the user into virtual narratives, turning them from a passive recipient into an actor. The importance of gamification as a tool for building strategies of internal stimulation with elements of entertaining practices in the dynamics of learning is also revealed, which increases the effectiveness of education. It has been revealed the significant educational potential of video games as a promising media platform in the framework of the implementation of the Digital Game Based Learning strategy. They can act both as carriers of knowledge and as a virtual environment for the formation of competencies in the field of history, economics, literature and social management. Procedural and rhetorical tools allow a person to become a part of an interactive scenario, which greatly increases the likelihood of assimilating information and developing professional skills.
Gender perspectives on educational contributions to the study of video-gaming: A baseline feminist genealogy

Cristina Valdés-Argüelles,Aquilina Fueyo Gutiérrez,María Verdeja

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3926/jotse.2621

2024-06-20

Journal of Technology and Science Education

Abstract:As video games have evolved, they have emerged as useful tools in areas such as education, tackling global issues through their storylines and mechanics. However, never in the history of video games, not even today, has there been parity in the proportion of women directly employed in the development of video games. This paper is part of a broader research project undertaken in the context of a doctoral thesis within the framework of the R+D+I project ' Building global citizenship with young people: researching transformative practices with participatory and inclusive methodologies' . It provides a historical perspective on video games and their place in culture and society, and attempts to outline a brief genealogy of the contributions of pioneering women in the video game industry. Recognising the work of women and addressing gender representation in video games is now a matter of great importance. Current trends in the video game industry reflect the impact of the pandemic on video game consumption habits, its expected continued growth in the future and its relationship with the development of virtual and augmented reality. Video games are therefore likely to remain an important part of culture and society in the future, with an ever-increasing role in education. It is therefore imperative to showcase the achievements of women in the video game industry, to highlight inequalities and to provide girls with genuine role models.
Gaming the Past– Commercial Video Games with historical contexts: Evaluation of the Iranian Lotf Ali Khan Game

Gheitasi,Joan Arnedo Moreno,Sorin Hermon,Marc Aurel Schnabel,Mahdi Gheitasi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21512/jggag.v8i1.9874

2023-06-26

Abstract:Virtual environments have numerous potentials for assisting the general public in experiencing cultural heritage, complementing current tools and practices centered on tangible goods such as museums, exhibitions, books, and visual content. Video games designed for educational purposes, which are becoming increasingly popular, have emerged as a new method of learning cultural content engagingly. The learning experience's specific goal distinguishes the educational use of video games. There is little doubt that we can learn from video games, but the more difficult questions about who, what, where, why, and how quickly we learn are not easily answered. This study examines the role of commercial video games in history learning and aims to enhance their effectiveness by analyzing their potential and limitations, using strategic planning and network analysis models. Through a case study on the Lotf Ali Khan game, it identifies strategies for improving history education through commercial video games. In this case study, it can be utilized to establish a conceptual framework for current trends in deployments of the past in historically focused video games, as well as a SWOT-ANP analysis to determine the major ways in which historical video games can aid in learning the subject matter under assessment. The data for this case study includes secondary sources and documents, fieldwork, observations, and semi-structured interviews with fifteen participants, as with other case studies (experts and children). Following the results, successful implementation occurs when a video game fully utilizes the following opportunities: antiquarian, monumental, and critical elements; wish story; composite imagination; borrowed authenticity; historical provenance; and legitimacy

English Else

The Great War and the Use of Video Games as Historical and Educational Resources: A Conversation

Digital Cultures of Commemoration: Learning and Unlearning History through Video Games

From pixels to pedagogy: using video games for higher education in the humanities

The role of video games in obtaining and disseminating historical knowledge

Gaming history: computer and video games as historical scholarship

Historical Video Games in the Context of Public History: Strategies for Reconstruction, Deconstruction and Politization of History

Video games as a screen-interactive platform of historical media education: educational potential and risks of politicization

Playing through to Europe? Depiction and Reception of the First World War in the Videogame Valiant Hearts

A future for game histories?

Video Games in Education: Why They Should Be Used and How They Are Being Used

A Game Design Plot: Exploring the Educational Potential of History-Based Video Games

A Dissection of Video Games as a medium of Art: The Utilization of Aesthetics and the Effectiveness of Video Games as a Tool in Curriculum

The interactive museum: Video games as history lessons through lore and affective design

Gamified Automation in Immersive Media for Education and Research

The Underexplored Synergy: Cinema as an Ally to the World Wars

History-Themed Games in History Education: Experiences on a Blended World History Course

Video games in the context of screen technoculture and media education: new rhetorical strategies and educational potential

Gender perspectives on educational contributions to the study of video-gaming: A baseline feminist genealogy

Gaming the Past– Commercial Video Games with historical contexts: Evaluation of the Iranian Lotf Ali Khan Game