Thomas Gallice,Emmanuelle Cugy,Olivier Branchard,Patrick Dehail,Geoffroy Moucheboeuf
Abstract:Neurological patients frequently have disorders of consciousness, swallowing disorders, or neurological states that are incompatible with extubation. Therefore, they frequently require tracheostomies during their stay in an intensive care unit. After the acute phase, tracheostomy weaning and decannulation are generally expected to promote rehabilitation. However, few reliable predictive factors (PFs) for decannulation have been identified in this patient population. We sought to identify PFs that may be used during tracheostomy weaning and decannulation in patients with brain injuries. We conducted a systematic review of the literature regarding potential PFs for decannulation; searches were performed on 16 March 2021 and 1 June 2022. The following databases were searched: MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Scopus, Web of Science, PEDro, OPENGREY, OPENSIGLE, Science Direct, CLINICAL TRIALS and CENTRAL. We searched for all article types, except systematic reviews, meta-analyses, abstracts, and position articles. Retrieved articles were published in English or French, with no date restriction. In total, 1433 articles were identified; 26 of these were eligible for inclusion in the review. PFs for successful decannulation in patients with acquired brain injuries (ABIs) included high neurological status, traumatic brain injuries rather than stroke or anoxic brain lesions, younger age, effective swallowing, an effective cough, and the absence of pulmonary infections. Secondary PFs included early tracheostomy, supratentorial lesions, the absence of critical illness polyneuropathy/myopathy, and the absence of tracheal lesions. To our knowledge, this is the first systematic review to identify PFs for decannulation in patients with ABIs. These PFs may be used by clinicians during tracheostomy weaning.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **Identify the predictive factors (PFs) for successful extubation in tracheostomy patients with brain injury**. Specifically, the author hopes to find reliable factors through a systematic review of the literature that can help clinicians predict success, failure, or difficulty during tracheostomy weaning and extubation.
### Background and Problem Description
Many neurology patients require tracheostomy during their stay in the intensive care unit (ICU) due to disorders of consciousness, swallowing disorders, or an inappropriate neurological state for extubation. After the acute phase, tracheostomy weaning and extubation are generally considered important steps to promote recovery. However, currently, there are still few and not reliable enough predictive factors (PFs) for extubation success in this patient group. Therefore, this paper aims to identify the predictive factors for successful tracheostomy weaning and extubation in patients with brain injury through a systematic review of the literature.
### Main Research Contents
1. **Research Subjects**: All brain - injured patients older than 18 years (including traumatic, vascular, encephalopathic, and neoplastic causes), excluding patients with spinal cord lesions or neurodegenerative diseases.
2. **Interventions**: Tracheostomy weaning and extubation.
3. **Control Group**: There is no control group.
4. **Outcome Indicators**: Predictive factors for successful extubation, including successful, failed, delayed, or difficult tracheostomy weaning.
### Research Methods
- **PICO Strategy**:
- **P (Population)**: All patients are brain - injured patients older than 18 years.
- **I (Intervention)**: Tracheostomy weaning and extubation.
- **C (Control)**: There is no control group.
- **O (Outcome)**: Predictive factors for successful extubation.
- **Data Sources**: Multiple databases were searched, including MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, Scopus, Web of Science, PEDro, OPENGREY, OPENSIGLE, Science Direct, CLINICAL TRIALS, and CENTRAL, with no time limit.
- **Screening Criteria**: Systematic reviews, meta - analyses, abstracts, and position papers were excluded, and only articles in English or French were included.
### Key Findings
By analyzing 26 eligible articles, the author summarized the following main predictive factors:
1. **High Neurological State**: Higher GCS scores and CRS - r scores.
2. **Traumatic Brain Injury rather than Stroke or Hypoxic Brain Injury**.
3. **Younger Age**: Younger patients are more likely to be successfully extubated.
4. **Effective Swallowing Function**: Good swallowing function is an important factor for successful extubation.
5. **Effective Cough Reflex**: There is a strong ability of voluntary or reflex cough.
6. **No Pulmonary Infection**: Patients without pulmonary infection are more likely to be successfully extubated.
In addition, secondary predictive factors also include early tracheostomy, supratentorial lesions, no severe polyneuropathy / myopathy, no airway injury, etc.
### Conclusion
This is the first systematic review specifically targeting the predictive factors for successful extubation in tracheostomy patients with brain injury. These predictive factors can help clinicians better assess and manage the tracheostomy weaning process, thereby increasing the success rate of patient recovery.
### Formula Examples (if any)
The statistical analysis involved in this paper uses a variety of statistics, for example:
- **Odds Ratio (OR)**: Used to measure the impact of a certain factor on the extubation success rate.
- **95% Confidence Interval (CI)**: Used to estimate the credible range of OR.
- **Hazard Ratio (HR)**: Used to assess the impact of risk factors on the extubation success rate.
For example:
\[ \text{OR} = 1.70, \quad 95\% \text{ CI} (1.20–2.43), \quad p = 0.003 \]
These formulas and statistics help quantify the impact of different factors on extubation success.