Concentric dual π delocalisation and conflicting aromaticity in bowl-like B56 cluster: an all-boron analogue of circumbiphenyl C38H16

Kang Wang,Peihuan Zhang,Yan Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00268976.2024.2420699
2024-10-30
Molecular Physics
Abstract:We present computational evidence for concentric dual π delocalisation and conflicting aromaticity in an elongated quasi-planar bowl-like B 56 ( C 2 v , 1 A 1 ) cluster, using the canonical molecular orbital (CMO) and the adaptive natural density partitioning (AdNDP) analyses at the density functional theory (DFT) level. The first B 12 and second B 18 rings constitute an inner BDR ribbon, and the second B 18 and third B 24 rings form an outer BDR ribbon. Chemical bonding analyses indicate that the 19 delocalised π bonds can be divided into two separate π subsystems, with inner 14π and outer 24π delocalised electrons. The bonding pattern is consistent with conflicting π aromaticity, which leads to an elongated geometry. A refined bonding model is also proposed for circumbiphenyl molecule C 38 H 16 , of which the B 56 cluster is an inorganic analogue. The updated bonding pictures differ from that reported in prior studies on the system. It is further unravelled the mechanism as to why the two hexagonal holes prefer to be located at the centre. This research enriches the analogous relationship between quasi-planar boron clusters and their polycyclic hydrocarbons counterparts. The bowl-like B 56 cluster is an all-boron analogue of the circumbiphenyl D 3h C 38 H 16 , featuring concentric dual π electron delocalisation bonding pattern with 14π and 24π electrons for the inner and outer boron ribbons, respectively. The π conflicting aromaticity naturally explains why the bowl-like B 56 cluster has an elongated form. This bonding model for the two species is established herein for the first time.
chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical
What problem does this paper attempt to address?