Spatial configuration analysis of a traditional garden in Yangzhou city: a comparative case study of three typical gardens

Wenting Wu,Kai Zhou,Tianjie Li,Xiaoling Dai

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/13467581.2023.2300391

IF: 0.904

2024-01-19

Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering

Abstract:This study examines the spatial layout characteristics of three existing traditional gardens from the 18th–19th century with featured historical backgrounds and landscape designs in Yangzhou City: Heyuan Garden (1862), Geyuan Garden (1818), and West Garden of the Daming Temple (1751). Two space syntax models, i.e. visibility graph analysis and segment angular analysis, were used to clarify the characteristics of the garden spaces. A quantitative analysis was conducted using statistical programs to reveal similarities and differences in invisible space-structure relationships among the three gardens. These gardens exhibited comparable centralities in terms of their accessibility distribution characteristics. The "mean depth" and "intelligibility" values were allocated such that visitors could access the global spaces effortlessly owing to the arrangement of these gardens. Scrutinising the "connectivity" parameter revealed that the intuitive perceptions of visitors were more diverse at the knee and eye levels because of the spatial structure of the gardens. This study can help understand the effect of cultural practices and societal norms on the design of traditional gardens. The findings of this study can aid in the conservation of cultural heritage and help restore the gardens in Yangzhou City from the perspective of analysing invisible space structures.

construction & building technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to analyze the spatial layout features of three typical traditional gardens in Yangzhou (Heyuan Garden, Geyuan Garden, and West Daming Temple Garden). The study uses spatial syntax models, including Visibility Graph Analysis (VGA) and Segment Angular Analysis (SAA), to quantify the hidden spatial structural relationships between different gardens. By calculating spatial accessibility distribution, spatial concentration, "average depth," and "comprehensibility," it reveals how these gardens are designed to enable visitors to easily access the overall space. The connectivity parameters at knee and eye levels show diverse intuitive perceptions due to spatial structure.

The paper points out that these traditional gardens were built by wealthy salt merchants in the 18th and 19th centuries, with unique historical backgrounds and landscape designs. Despite being affected by economic decline and war destruction, a few of them have been preserved. Studying these gardens helps understand the influence of cultural customs and social norms on the design of traditional gardens, providing a basis for cultural heritage preservation and the restoration of Yangzhou gardens. Current research on traditional gardens mainly focuses on northern imperial gardens and Suzhou gardens, while this study fills the gap in quantitative analysis of spatial configurations of Yangzhou gardens.

Through spatial syntax models, the authors found that the spatial layouts of these three gardens centralize the connection between architectural space and landscape space, providing convenient tour paths. Moreover, in terms of visual perception, landscape space is generally more open and permeable than architectural space. In addition, the study also indicates that the "comprehensibility" of space is low, suggesting that visitors may feel lost in the overall space, reflecting the complexity of spatial design.

In conclusion, this paper reveals the commonalities and differences in spatial configurations of traditional gardens in Yangzhou through comparative analysis, providing new perspectives and methods for understanding and preserving this cultural heritage.