Abstract:Abstract Most unretirement research has focused on single countries, indicating that socio-economic advantage and financial need predict unretirement in particular settings. Remarkably, little is known about whether the frequency and predictors of unretirement—returning to paid work after ceasing work at retirement—vary in relation to the country setting. We followed recent retirees over time in Germany, Russia, and the United Kingdom to compare unretirement rates and predictors, and whether financial need predicted unretirement in a middle-income setting rather than in a high-income setting. We harmonized data ex post from four prospective surveys: German Socio-Economic Panel Study (1991–2016), Russian Longitudinal Monitoring Survey (1994–2016), and for the United Kingdom, British Household Panel Survey (1991–2008), and Understanding Society (2010–2015). Unretirement was examined using Cox regression in relation to gender, age, education, health, household income, and financial difficulties. After 20 years of follow-up, the cumulative hazard of unretirement attained 0.20 in German, 0.24 in British, and 0.40 in Russian participants. Unretirement rates were generally higher for retirees who were younger, in better health and had higher household income. Worries about finances did not predict unretirement in Russia; such concerns predicted higher unretirement rates only in fully adjusted models in Germany and the United Kingdom. Since retirees in financial need may have difficulties finding suitable jobs, unretirement is a process with the potential to deepen financial inequality in later life. Variations in unretirement rates and predictors across countries demonstrate the importance of extending unretirement research to incorporate a cross-national comparative perspective.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The main issue this paper attempts to address is whether the frequency and predictors of post-retirement reemployment (i.e., "unretirement") differ between countries. Specifically, the authors focus on Germany, Russia, and the United Kingdom, comparing the rates of post-retirement reemployment and their predictors in these countries to explore the impact of socio-economic backgrounds on post-retirement reemployment.
### Main Research Questions:
1. **Is there a difference in post-retirement reemployment rates between countries?**
- The researchers aim to understand whether the proportion of retirees returning to work after retirement differs between Germany, Russia, and the United Kingdom.
2. **Do the predictors of post-retirement reemployment differ between countries?**
- By analyzing factors such as gender, age, education level, health status, household income, and financial difficulties, the researchers aim to explore whether these factors have a consistent impact on post-retirement reemployment across different countries.
3. **Does financial need have a different impact in middle-income countries (such as Russia) compared to high-income countries (such as Germany and the United Kingdom)?**
- The researchers are particularly interested in whether financial need is a stronger predictor of post-retirement reemployment in middle-income countries (such as Russia) compared to high-income countries (such as Germany and the United Kingdom).
### Background and Motivation:
- **Limitations of existing research**: Most studies on post-retirement reemployment focus on a single country and primarily on North American and Western European countries. This approach limits the understanding of post-retirement reemployment in other country contexts.
- **Importance of cross-country comparison**: Cross-country comparisons can provide a better understanding of post-retirement reemployment patterns in different socio-economic contexts, offering more valuable insights for policy-making.
- **Methodological improvements**: The researchers used four prospective survey datasets and applied uniform data processing and analysis methods to ensure the comparability and reliability of the results.
### Hypotheses:
1. **Hypothesis 1 (H1)**: Germany has the lowest post-retirement reemployment rate, Russia the highest, and the United Kingdom falls in between.
- Germany's pension system is relatively well-developed, with a low poverty rate among the elderly and labor market policies favoring early retirement, leading to a lower post-retirement reemployment rate.
- Russia has a lower standard of living for the elderly, a labor market logic that favors maintaining employment, and a tradition of supplementary pensions, leading to a higher post-retirement reemployment rate.
- The United Kingdom has a more flexible labor market and a moderate risk of a decline in living standards after retirement, leading to a post-retirement reemployment rate between Germany and Russia.
2. **Hypothesis 2 (H2)**: In Germany and the United Kingdom (but not in Russia), those groups with higher labor market demand (male, younger, healthy, highly educated retirees) are more likely to reenter the workforce.
- In Germany and the United Kingdom, post-retirement reemployment is more of a voluntary choice, making these advantaged groups more likely to reenter the workforce.
- In Russia, financial need is the main driving factor, making low-income groups more likely to reenter the workforce due to economic pressure.
Through these research questions and hypotheses, the paper aims to fill gaps in existing research and provide scientific evidence for retirement policies in different countries.