Abstract:We evaluate the skills of ocean–sea ice general circulation models involved in the Ocean Modeling Intercomparison Project in simulating the ocean mixed layer depth and its seasonal cycle in the Arctic region. During summer months, all models consistently underestimate the mixed layer depth compared to observational data from the Monthly Isopycnal Mixed layer Ocean Climatology and the Ice Tethered Profilers. In fall and winter, the models exhibit great variability compared to observational data, and inter-model comparison reveals differences up to several tens of meters. We analyze the origin of the fall and winter model biases in ice-covered regions, where the seasonal cycle of the surface salinity and mixed layer depth is strongly influenced by brine rejection resulting from ocean–sea ice interactions. Focusing first on the central Arctic Ocean, defined here as the region north of 80 ° N, we show that all models simulate more or less the same vertical sea ice mass balance and thus similar salt fluxes into the ocean during sea ice freezing. Furthermore, the model ensemble features a strong relationship between the stratification profile in September and the mixed layer depth at the end of winter. The models whose stratification compares the best to observational data also display the most realistic values of the mixed layer depth at the end of winter. We argue that the discrepancies between models are therefore not so much linked to the surface salt balance but rather to the accuracy with which those models reproduce the vertical salinity profile. In short, a weakly stratified ocean tends to create a deep mixed layer, while strong stratification leads to a shallow mixed layer. To substantiate this conclusion, we apply a simple conceptual model, which simulates the month-to-month evolution of the mixed layer depth using as input the vertical salinity gradients and the surface salt fluxes from general circulation models. Quite surprisingly, this simplified dynamics captures very well the behavior of the general circulation models, emphasizing the role of the different vertical stratification in the control of the mixed layer depth. Furthermore, this interplay may also significantly account for the large mixed layer biases observed in other ice-covered regions of the pan-Arctic seas, even though sea–ice ocean interaction is not the only driver of mixed layer variability in fall and winter there.

The interaction of seasonality and low-frequencies in a stochastic Arctic sea ice model

The Influence of Tropical Pacific Forcing on the Arctic Oscillation

On the existence of stable seasonally varying Arctic sea ice in simple models

A Low Order Theory of Arctic Sea Ice Stability

Understanding Influence of Ocean Waves on Arctic Sea Ice Simulation: A Modeling Study with an Atmosphere-Ocean-wave-sea Ice Coupled Model

A stochastic model for the turbulent ocean heat flux under Arctic sea ice

Seasonal and Interannual Variability of the Arctic Sea Ice: A Comparison Between AO-FVCOM and Observations

Understanding the influence of ocean waves on Arctic sea ice simulation: a modeling study with an atmosphere–ocean–wave–sea ice coupled model

On the annual and semi-annual components of variations in extent of Arctic and Antarctic sea-ice

Seasonal evolution of the Arctic sea ice thickness distribution

Impact of Local Atmospheric Intraseasonal Variability on Mean Sea Ice State in the Arctic Ocean

Reconciling Roles of External Forcing and Internal Variability in Arctic Sea Ice Change on Different Timescales

Modeling of climate tendencies in Arctic seas based on atmospheric forcing EOF decomposition

An interannual link between Arctic sea-ice cover and the North Atlantic Oscillation

On the ability of OMIP models to simulate the ocean mixed layer depth and its seasonal cycle in the Arctic Ocean

Arctic Sea Ice Seasonal Prediction by a Linear Markov Model

Large-Scale Climate Modes Drive Low-Frequency Regional Arctic Sea Ice Variability

Important influence of North Atlantic Oscillation on interannual variability of the boreal autumn East Siberian-Beaufort Sea ice

Glacial abrupt climate change as a multi-scale phenomenon resulting from monostable excitable dynamics

Seesaw structure of subsurface temperature anomalies between the Barents Sea and the Labrador Sea