Abstract:BackgroundThree dimensional (3D) genome spatial organization is critical for numerous cellular functions, including transcription, while certain conformation-driven structural alterations are frequently oncogenic. Genome conformation had been difficult to elucidate but the advent chromatin conformation capture assays, notably Hi-C, has transformed understanding of chromatin architecture and yielded numerous biological insights. Although most of these findings have flowed from analysis of proximity data produced by these assays, added value in generating 3D reconstructions has been demonstrated, deriving, in part, from superposing genomic features on the reconstruction. However, advantages of 3D structure-based analyses are clearly conditional on the accuracy of the attendant reconstructions, which is difficult to assess. Proponents of competing reconstruction algorithms have evaluated their accuracy by recourse to simulation of toy structures and/or limited fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) imaging that features a handful of low resolution probes. Accordingly, new methods of reconstruction accuracy assessment are needed.ResultsHere we utilize two recently devised assays to develop methodology for assessing 3D reconstruction accuracy. Multiplex FISH increases the number of probes by an order of magnitude and hence the number of inter-probe distances by two orders, providing sufficient information for structure-level evaluation via mean-squared deviations (MSD). Crucially, underscoring multiplex FISH applications are large numbers of coordinate-system aligned replicates that provide the basis for a referent distribution for MSD statistics. Using this system we show that reconstructions based on Hi-C data for IMR90 cells are accurate for some chromosomes but not others. The second new assay, genome architecture mapping, utilizes large numbers of thin cryosections to obtain a measure of proximity. We exploit the planarity of the cryosections – not used in inferring proximity – to obtain measures of reconstruction accuracy, with referents provided via resampling. Application to mouse embryonic stem cells shows reconstruction accuracies that vary by chromosome.ConclusionsWe have developed methods for assessing the accuracy of 3D genome reconstructions that exploit features of recently advanced multiplex FISH and genome architecture mapping assays. These approaches can help overcome the absence of gold standards for making such assessments which are important in view of the considerable uncertainties surrounding 3D genome reconstruction.

Chromatin 3D Reconstruction from Chromosomal Contacts Using a Genetic Algorithm

Inference of the three-dimensional chromatin structure and its temporal behavior

The Advancement of Analysis Methods of Chromosome Conformation Capture Data

Reconstruction of Three-Dimensional Structures of Chromatin and Its Biological Implications

Efficient Hi-C Inversion Facilitates Chromatin Folding Mechanism Discovery and Structure Prediction

A 3-D Chromosome Structure Reconstruction Method with High Resolution Hi-C Data Using Nonlinear Dimensionality Reduction and Divide-and-Conquer Strategy.

A 3D Chromosome Structure Reconstruction method with High Resolution Hi-C Data using Nonlinear Dimensionality Reduction and Divide-and-conquer strategy

ParticleChromo3D: a Particle Swarm Optimization algorithm for chromosome 3D structure prediction from Hi-C data

Predicting chromatin conformation contact maps

EVRC: reconstruction of chromosome 3D structure models using error-vector resultant algorithm with clustering coefficient

Direct CCUT: A Versatile and Standardized Framework to Train 3C Deep Restoration Models

Improved accuracy assessment for 3D genome reconstructions

Reconstructing high-resolution chromosome three-dimensional structures by Hi-C complex networks

Using DNase Hi-C techniques to map global and local three-dimensional genome architecture at high resolution

An Overview of Methods for Reconstructing 3-D Chromosome and Genome Structures from Hi-C Data

3D Genome Reconstruction from Partially Phased Hi-C Data

Advances in technologies for 3D genomics research

Reconstruction of Diploid High-Order 3D Genome Interactions from Long Noisy Concatemers

Connecting high-resolution 3D chromatin organization with epigenomics

ChIP-based methods for the identification of long-range chromatin interactions.