An Evaluation of Different Landscape Design Scenarios to Improve Outdoor Thermal Comfort in Shenzhen

Ying Zheng,Qiyao Han,Greg Keeffe

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/land13010065

IF: 3.905

2024-01-07

Land

Abstract:The pivotal role of urban greening in landscape design for mitigating climate change and enhancing the thermal environment is widely known. However, numerous evaluations of outdoor thermal comfort are seldom applied within the realm of landscape design scenarios. This study explores the relationship between street design and urban microclimate, aiming to propose a range of design strategies that can significantly improve thermal comfort within the street environment in Shenzhen, China. These design strategies hold immense potential for urban greening implementation and provide valuable insights to enhance the overall thermal quality of streetscapes in subtropical cities. The study employs landscape design and environmental simulation methods to evaluate the different design scenarios for the streetscape. The landscape design encompasses three scenarios with revised interventions: 1. the incorporation of building greening and enhanced pavement material albedo; 2. the introduction of trees and grass at the ground level; and 3. a combination of scenarios 1 and 2. Environmental simulations are utilized to assess the effectiveness of each design scenario. The findings reveal that increasing urban vegetation leads to a reduction in urban heat and significantly improves outdoor thermal comfort. Moreover, the incorporation of shade-providing trees proves to be more efficacious than employing vertical greening in alleviating outdoor thermal discomfort.

environmental studies

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main aim of this paper is to address the issue of how urban street landscape design can improve outdoor thermal comfort. Specifically, the study focuses on Shenzhen, China, a city characterized by a subtropical climate, and evaluates the impact of different street landscape design schemes on urban microclimate and outdoor thermal comfort.

The study proposes three key design schemes:

1. **Building Greening and Enhanced Ground Material Albedo**: Increasing vegetation on buildings and changing ground materials to improve albedo.
2. **Introduction of Trees and Grass at Ground Level**: Planting native tree species (such as Tabebuia) and grass at the sidewalk level.
3. **Combination of the Above Two Schemes**: Integrating building greening, ground material improvement, and the planting of trees and grass.

Using environmental simulation methods, the researchers assessed the effectiveness of these design strategies. The results indicate that increasing urban vegetation can significantly reduce urban temperatures and improve outdoor thermal comfort. Additionally, trees providing shade are more effective in alleviating outdoor thermal discomfort than vertical greening.

In summary, the goal of this paper is to quantify the cooling effects of landscape design on outdoor thermal comfort and to identify which landscape elements can significantly contribute to this effect. This provides new insights for urban landscape design and planning, particularly in mitigating urban heat island effects and enhancing outdoor thermal comfort through landscape design.