Spatial distribution and risk factors of adverse treatment outcomes of tuberculosis in Guizhou, China, 2013–2018

Jian Zhou,Xiaoxue Ma,Juan Tian,Feng Hong,Jinlan Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-86994-6
IF: 4.6
2021-04-08
Scientific Reports
Abstract:Abstract The incidence of Tuberculosis (TB) in Guizhou province has ranked to be the top four among the 31 China provinces. The spatial distribution and influencing factors of adverse outcomes of TB in Guizhou are unclear. In our study, the cases information of TB in Guizhou province from 2013 to 2018 was collected, we analyzed the spatial distribution and clusters of five adverse outcomes of TB with ArcMap10.2 software, used logistics regression analysis to assessed risk factors and used Chi-square analysis to analyze variation trend of the five adverse outcomes. A total of 237, 806 cases information of TB were collected. The proportion of adverse outcomes in TB patients was 6.18%, among which adverse reactions accounted for 1.05%, lost to follow-up accounted for 1.44%, treatment failed accounted for 1.15%, died accounted for 2.31%, switch to MDR accounted for 0.24%. The component ratio of adverse outcomes showed an upward trend ( P < 0.05).Regional clustering existed in each of adverse outcomes ( P < 0.05). There were high-risk minorities, gender, age, occupation, type of diagnosis, Therapeutic category existed in adverse outcomes of TB. Miao and Dong had a higher risk in adverse reaction of TB compared with Han. Women had a higher risk in adverse reactions than men, and a lower risk of lost to follow-up, failed, and died. Retreated patients had a higher risk of adverse outcomes. Timely monitoring and active intervention should be carried out for some high-risk areas and groups, including middle-aged and elderly patients, rural patients, floating patients, severe patients and retreated patients during the process of patient diagnosis and treatment.
multidisciplinary sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to analyze the spatial distribution and risk factors of adverse treatment outcomes of tuberculosis (TB) in Guizhou province, China from 2013 to 2018. Specifically, the study aims to: 1. **Analyze temporal and spatial characteristics**: Study the temporal and spatial characteristics of five adverse treatment outcomes of tuberculosis, including adverse reactions, loss to follow - up, treatment failure, death, and conversion to multi - drug - resistant tuberculosis (MDR). 2. **Evaluate risk factors**: Evaluate the risk factors of these adverse treatment outcomes through univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses. 3. **Describe change trends**: Analyze the change trends of these five adverse treatment outcomes using the chi - square test. ### Research background - The incidence of tuberculosis in Guizhou province ranks among the top four among China's 31 provinces. - The spatial distribution and influencing factors of tuberculosis in Guizhou are still unclear. - This study collected information on 237,806 tuberculosis patients in Guizhou province between 2013 and 2018, used ArcMap 10.2 software to analyze the spatial distribution and clustering of adverse treatment outcomes, and evaluated risk factors through logistic regression analysis. ### Main findings - **Proportion of adverse treatment outcomes**: The proportion of adverse treatment outcomes among tuberculosis patients is 6.18%, of which adverse reactions account for 1.05%, loss to follow - up accounts for 1.44%, treatment failure accounts for 1.15%, death accounts for 2.31%, and conversion to multi - drug - resistant tuberculosis accounts for 0.24%. - **Change trends**: The proportion of overall adverse treatment outcomes shows an upward trend (P < 0.05), among which the proportion of adverse reactions shows a downward trend (P < 0.05), while the proportions of loss to follow - up, treatment failure, death, and conversion to multi - drug - resistant tuberculosis show an upward trend (P < 0.05). - **Spatial distribution and clustering**: There is a clustering phenomenon in the spatial distribution of adverse treatment outcomes, and different types of adverse outcomes show different clustering characteristics in different regions. - **Risk factors**: - **Gender**: Women have a higher risk in terms of adverse reactions, but a lower risk in terms of loss to follow - up, treatment failure, and death. - **Age**: The older the age, the higher the risk of adverse reactions, treatment failure, and death. - **Ethnic group**: The Miao and Dong ethnic groups have a higher risk in terms of adverse reactions, while the Bouyei and Tujia ethnic groups have a lower risk. - **Occupation**: Retirees and cadres have a higher risk in terms of adverse reactions and treatment failure, while students have a lower risk in terms of adverse reactions and treatment failure. - **Patient source**: Non - local patients have a higher risk in terms of loss to follow - up and death. - **Clinical classification**: Different types of tuberculosis patients have different risks in terms of different adverse outcomes. - **Diagnosis result**: Negative etiology and simple tuberculous pleurisy have a higher risk in terms of adverse reactions and treatment failure. - **Severity**: Non - severe patients have a higher risk in terms of adverse reactions, loss to follow - up, and treatment failure. - **Treatment category**: Retreated patients have a higher risk in all adverse outcomes. ### Conclusion This study provides a detailed analysis of the temporal and spatial characteristics and risk factors of adverse treatment outcomes of tuberculosis in Guizhou province, which is helpful for timely monitoring and active intervention in high - risk areas and groups, thereby improving the treatment outcomes of tuberculosis patients.