Abstract:Developmental constraints have been postulated to limit the space of feasible phenotypes and thus shape animal evolution. These constraints have been suggested to be the strongest during either early or mid-embryogenesis, which corresponds to the early conservation model or the hourglass model, respectively. Conflicting results have been reported, but in recent studies of animal transcriptomes the hourglass model has been favored. Studies usually report descriptive statistics calculated for all genes over all developmental time points. This introduces dependencies between the sets of compared genes, and may lead to biased results. Here we overcome this problem using an alternative modular analysis. We used the Iterative Signature Algorithm to identify distinct modules of genes co-expressed specifically in consecutive stages of zebrafish development. We then performed a detailed comparison of several gene properties between modules, allowing for a less biased and more powerful analysis. Notably, our analysis corroborated the hourglass pattern only at the regulatory level, with sequences of regulatory regions being most conserved for genes expressed in mid-development, but not at the level of gene sequence, age or expression, in contrast to some previous studies. The early conservation model was supported with gene duplication and birth that were the most rare for genes expressed in early development. Finally, for all gene properties we observed the least conservation for genes expressed in late development or adult, consistent with both models. Overall, with the modular approach, we showed that different levels of molecular evolution follow different patterns of developmental constraints. Thus both models are valid, but with respect to different genomic features.

The stem cell zoo for comparative studies of developmental tempo

A stem cell zoo uncovers intracellular scaling of developmental tempo across mammals

A cell state splitter and differentiation wave working-model for embryonic stem cell development and somatic cell epigenetic reprogramming.

Metabolism in Pluripotent Stem Cells and Early Mammalian Development

Metabolic mechanisms of species-specific developmental tempo

Species-specific pace of development is associated with differences in protein stability

Emerging Roles of Single-Cell Multi-Omics in Studying Developmental Temporal Patterning

Timing mechanisms: insights from comparative neural differentiation systems

A Zebrafish Mosaic Assay to Study Mammalian Stem Cells in Real Time in Vivo

Stem cells: a view from the roots

Dynamic Pluripotent Stem Cell States and Their Applications.

What does time mean in development?

The hourglass and the early conservation models - co-existing evolutionary patterns in vertebrate development

Embryonic timing, axial stem cells, chromatin dynamics, and the Hox clock

Understanding how cells and organisms keep time during development

Inter-cellular Interactions and Patterns: Vertebrate Development and Embryonic Stem Cells

Pluripotent stem cell models of early mammalian development

Stem Cells: A Renaissance in Human Biology Research

Past and future of human developmental biology

Dissecting the spatiotemporal diversity of adult neural stem cells

A multicellular developmental program in a close animal relative