Abstract:Assuming that the well-confirmed non-classical rotational inertia (NCRI) effect in solid $^4$He, suggested by Leggett, indicates supersolid behavior, we make a number of remarks about both theory and experiment. (1) The long-wavelength, low-frequency ("hydrodynamic") part of the theory of Andreev and Lifshitz has nine variables, and thus must have nine modes. We find a new mode associated with lattice point diffusion (and thus vacancy diffusion); it may explain the absence of supersolid behavior in low-frequency pressure-driven flow. (2) The observed upper limit for the NCRI fraction (NCRIf) of about 20%, in disordered samples, is more-or-less the same as the already predicted upper limit for the superfluid fraction of a well-ordered crystal; we argue that this may not be a coincidence. (3) The negative experimental evidence for a second propagating hydrodynamic mode (expected to be fourth sound-like) may be due to the long relaxation times $\tau$ at low temperature $T$; only for frequencies satisfying $\omega\tau\ll1$ does the hydrodynamic theory apply. (4) The fundamental principles of quantum mechanics imply that Bose-Einstein condensation is not necessary to define a quantum-mechanical phase; therefore the absence of a finite condensate fraction $f_{0}$ does not necessarily imply the absence of superfluidity. (5) Just as vortices should avoid occupied lattice sites to provide a vortex-lattice interaction, the lattice should interact with the vortices to provide a lattice-vortex interaction; thus dislocations should interact with vortices, whose motion is affected by rotation. We discuss some experimental implications for the vortex liquid model, shear response, hysteresis, and relaxation.

How to Prepare an Ideal Helium 4 Crystal

Dynamics of a $^4$He quantum crystal in the superfluid liquid

Dislocation networks in helium-4 crystals

Phase diagram and crystal melting of helium-4 in two dimensions

Phase separation in solid mixtures of helium-3 and helium-4

Interplay of non-linear elasticity and dislocation-induced superfluidity in solid Helium-4

Creating two-dimensional solid helium via diamond lattice confinement

Supersolidity in ultra-cold dipolar gases

Excited electron-bubble states in superfluid helium-4: a time-dependent density functional approach

Torsional oscillator and synchrotron x-ray experiments on solid 4He in aerogel

Comments On Supersolidity

Manifestations of Local Supersolidity of $^{4}$He around a Charged Molecular Impurity

Thermal and structural properties of topological defects in solid Helium-4: Strain induced martensitic transformation from hcp to fc orthorhombic lattice

Hydrodynamic properties of the perfect hard-sphere crystal: Microscopic computations with Helfand moments

Equation Of State And Phase-Diagram Of Solid He-4 From Single-Crystal X-Ray-Diffraction Over A Large P-T Domain

Comment on "Giant Plasticity of a Quantum Crystal"

High-Pressure Phase-Diagram And Equation Of State Of Solid Helium From Single-Crystal X-Ray-Diffraction To 23.3-Gpa

Anomalously Small Excitation Gaps as a Precursor of Dislocation Core Superfluidity in Solid Helium-4

Helium at elevated pressures: Quantum liquid with non-static shear rigidity

Equation of State and Phase Diagram of Solidhe4from Single-Crystal X-Ray Diffraction over a Largep-Tdomain

The role of Helium-3 impurities in the stress induced roughening of superclimbing dislocations in solid Helium-4