Abstract:A growing literature demonstrates reluctant giving: Many people who voluntarily give to charity no longer do so when they have an excuse not to give. The mechanisms of reluctance, however, remain unclear. Consistent with this literature, we found that injecting attributional ambiguity into a real charitable decision significantly reduces donations. Participants in our studies (N = 2147) faced a binary choice between options for distributing money between themselves and a charity, with one option giving more to a charity and the other leaving more for themselves. Borrowing from a classic attributional ambiguity paradigm, we manipulated whether the charity involved was the same for both options or different, giving participants the possible excuse of keeping more money due to preferring one charity over another. Participants indeed kept more for themselves when there were two different charities, regardless of which charity was associated with the more self-beneficial option, ostensibly revealing a hidden preference for selfishness. Using incentive compatible elications, we found no evidence that participants used the excuse of preferring one charity to another to justify their choices. Instead, we find that attributional ambiguity weakened perceptions that there is a norm against keeping more money in the task, both among decision makers and disinterested third parties. We conclude that attributional ambiguity lowers donations by relieving internalized social pressure to give.

Tax Incentives for Charitable Giving: New Findings from the TCJA

Does Understanding Tax Laws Reduce Charitable Giving? A Study of Tax Literacy and Unintended Consequences*

More Giving or More Givers? The Effects of Tax Incentives on Charitable Donations in the UK

Does tax policy matter for donating behaviour? evidence from the korean tax reform

Tax Incentives for Charitable Giving as a Policy Instrument: Theoretical Discussion and Latest Economic Research

Is Charitable Giving Political? New Evidence from Wealth and Income Tax Returns

Tax Incentives and Charitable Contributions: the Evidence from Censored Quantile Regression

An assessment of the impact of tax incentives relative to socio-economic characteristics on charitable giving in Canada

Productivity effects of corporate income tax: Evidence from China

Tax Incentive and Firm Investment: Evidence from the Income Tax Revenue Sharing Reform in China

Tax incentives for corporate giving programs: what measures increase funds available?

Price Elasticities of Charitable Giving across Donation Sectors in Canada: Is the Tax Incentive Effective?

A ROBUST ESTIMATION OF THE EFFECTS OF TAXATION ON CHARITABLE CONTRIBUTIONS

Giving and Getting: Charitable Activity and Public Assistance

The consequences of the 2017 US international tax reform: a survey of the evidence

Does the effectiveness of tax incentives on the decision to give charitable donations vary across donation sectors in Canada?

Think Tank Soldiers in the Battle for Tax Reform

Attributional ambiguity reduces charitable giving by relaxing social norms

Short-Term Effects of Tax Credits on Rates of Child Maltreatment Reports in the United States.

The Macroeconomic Effects of Corporate Tax Reforms

Status Incentives and Corporate Giving: Evidence from China's Political Reform on Private Enterprises