#2320 The impact of interventions for people with chronic kidney disease on health-related quality of life: a systematic review
Thomas Phillips,Keegan Lee,Olalekan Lee Aiyegbusi,Paul Cockwell,Philip A Kalra,Paul Roderick,David C Wheeler,Kristin Veighey,Ashley I Heinson,Maarten W Taal,Simon Fraser
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/ndt/gfae069.569
IF: 7.1857
2024-05-01
Nephrology Dialysis Transplantation
Abstract:Abstract Background and Aims Health-related quality of life (HRQoL) is poorer for those with chronic kidney disease (CKD) than the general population and worsens as CKD progresses. Evidence is mixed as to which interventions improve HRQoL for those with CKD, and HRQoL is often under-reported in randomised controlled trials where it is most commonly a secondary outcome. Reviews including HRQoL as an outcome have thus far focused on the impact per intervention, therefore we aimed to ascertain which interventions, of any type, have an impact on HRQoL outcomes for those with non-dialysis dependent CKD (NDD-CKD). Method The protocol was prospectively registered on PROSPERO (CRD42022364474) and PRISMA guidelines were followed. Inclusion criteria were randomised controlled trials in an NDD-CKD population (excluding transplant recipients), any intervention type, usual care/placebo comparators, using validated and reported HRQoL outcomes measures. Databases searched were Embase, Medline, PsychINFO, CINAHL plus, Web of Science, PubMed, and Google Scholar, with reference searching of included studies. Reports were independently screened by two researchers who also performed data extraction and quality assessment (using the Cochrane Risk of Bias 2.0 tool). Synthesis was undertaken using Synthesis without Meta-analysis (SWiM) methods. Conversion to one-sided p-values, synthesising outcomes in albatross plots and combining p-values via Fisher's method was performed using the metap package in R. HRQoL measures were broken down into physical, mental, kidney disease symptoms, adverse effects of kidney disease, burden of kidney disease, overall kidney disease, and overall HRQoL domains for analysis. Results Searches yielded 8983 records, and 39 studies met inclusion criteria, with a total of 11,940 participants. Nine groups were formed based on type of intervention, with data synthesis possible in the eight groups with more than one study (Fig. 1). 26 (66%) studies were rated as having high risk of bias, largely due to frequent lack of blinding and HRQoL being a patient reported outcome. 37 studies had sufficient data for presentation in albatross plots (Fig. 2). Using combined p-values for all HRQoL outcomes in each group of studies, benefit to HRQoL in at least one study was shown for education interventions (p < 0.001, seven studies, none with low risk of bias), exercise interventions (p < 0.001, eight studies, all with high risk of bias), medications to treat CKD-related anaemia (p < 0.001, eight studies, four with low risk of bias), nutritional interventions (p < 0.001, four studies, all with high risk of bias) and weight loss interventions (p < 0.001, two studies, one with low risk of bias). No benefit to HRQoL was shown for medications aimed at slowing CKD progression (p = 0.492, five studies), medications for depression (p = 0.266, two studies) and medications to treat acidosis (p = 0.99, two studies). Conclusion This review identified several interventions with evidence of benefit to HRQoL for people with NDD-CKD, including medications to treat anaemia and weight loss interventions. Studies of education, exercise and nutritional interventions showed potential benefit, but with high risk of bias. Further high-quality randomised controlled trials of interventions for people with NDD-CKD should include and report HRQoL outcomes, in addition to targeting potentially modifiable determinants of HRQoL in these groups.
urology & nephrology,transplantation