Preterm and Early-Term Birth, Heat Waves, and Our Changing Climate
Caleb Dresser,Shruthi Mahalingaiah,Kari C. Nadeau
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2024.12026
2024-05-25
JAMA Network Open
Abstract:Heat waves pose an escalating threat to human health in general and the health of pregnant people and infants in particular. Darrow et al 1 used 2 large datasets—a natality database that includes 55 million recent US births and a 1-km 2 grid of historical daily temperatures—to demonstrate an association between heat waves and rates of preterm and early-term births. The authors identify important positive associations of preterm and early-term birth with hotter, longer heat waves among lower socioeconomic status subgroups, as well as among Hispanic and non-Hispanic Black mothers. While associations of extreme heat with hospitalizations, suicides, mortality, and other health outcomes among older adults and the general population are increasingly well understood, the association of extreme heat with time to conception, pregnancy loss, and general health of pregnant individuals and infants are less-often discussed. 2 ,3 Furthermore, prenatal exposure to extreme heat may also have effects across the lifespan, including early childhood development, pubertal transition, and reproductive function. The findings of Darrow et al 1 are consistent with other studies that have demonstrated positive associations between extreme heat and increased rates of stillbirths, premature births, and lower-birth-weight babies. Importantly, Darrow et al 1 address the heterogeneity of most prior studies that have varying definitions of excessive heat. Their definition of hot days that adjusted for the 97.5th percentile of the mean temperature adds a critical understanding that pregnancies in areas that are typically cool and dry will be affected as much as those that are in areas that are typically hot and humid. This study represents an important step forward in our understanding of the perinatal risk associated with heat wave exposure and builds on a rapidly expanding literature on the association of extreme heat with pregnancy and birth outcomes. In addition to the association of heat with fetal development, heat has especially powerful effects on infants, particularly those who are born premature or early term, and can lead to disruptions in sleep, mental health, and behavioral health. In a 2020 systematic review, Bekkar et al 4 reviewed 68 studies comprising a total of more than 32 million births, finding that, of a subset of 10 studies investigating the impacts of heat, 9 identified associations between heat and adverse birth outcomes, such as preterm birth, low birth weight, and stillbirth. A review the following year identified 13 studies on links between heat exposure and congenital anomalies, principally with regard to heat exposure in the first trimester; while results included some null studies using self-recalled temperature, 10 of the studies found associations between heat exposure and congenital anomalies, including heart anomalies, neural tube defects, and facial and craniofacial abnormalities, as well as other conditions, including hypospadias. 5 Although the association of exposure to extreme heat with adverse pregnancy and fetal outcomes is increasingly clear, the immediate and lifelong effects of prematurity are typically excluded from assessments of the effects of heat from both a health and economic perspective. As the authors note, prematurity is a leading cause of mortality in the neonatal period and increases a child's risk of respiratory disease, cognitive impairments, and behavioral challenges. By failing to include these implications of preterm and early-term births in public health assessments, we vastly underestimate the effects of heat on population health. The sample size of more than 55 million births in the study by Darrow et al 1 compares favorably with previous studies, providing validation of the outcomes they studied throughout major US metropolitan areas. These results are part of a larger trend toward the use of large nationally representative health outcomes datasets in combination with spatially and temporally resolved information on historical exposures, such as heat, air quality, and other hazards. 6 These exposure datasets are being developed by both academic research groups and government agencies using combinations of historical weather station records, remote-sensing data, and interpolation and missing data smoothing techniques. Studies using such datasets represent a substantial step forward in terms of understanding individual environmental exposures across lengthy time spans and large geographic regions, and substantial opportunities exist to better understand the association between a variety of health outcomes and environmental hazards that are of increasing importance in the context of climate change. Darrow et al 1 are timely in their engagement with heat, which is one of the principal physical threats that populations, pa -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal