Values and National Identification in Minority and Majority Youth: Longitudinal Multi-Study Findings

Maya Benish-Weisman,Ella Daniel,Einat Elizarov,Noga Sverdlik,Peter F. Titzmann
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10964-024-01965-0
2024-03-16
Journal of Youth and Adolescence
Abstract:Collective identification is vital for adolescents, fostering well-being and connection, but scant attention has been given to drivers of national identification and their contextual variations in youth. To address this, two longitudinal studies examined how values, as guiding goals defining what individuals consider important in their lives, relate to the trajectory of national identification in majority and minority youth. Study 1 ( N = 568; M age = 16.24, SD = 0.71) and Study 2 ( N = 678; M age = 13.78, SD = 0.73) focused on majority youth (Jewish-Israelis), while Study 2 also included minority (Arab citizens of Israel). The findings highlight values as important motivators of national identification over time. Conservation values, emphasizing the preservation of the status quo and a preference for stability, were prominent motivators for the majority of adolescents. In contrast, power values, which center around climbing the social ladder and accumulating wealth, held greater significance among their minority counterparts; however, both sets of values correlated with increased national identification. The discussion touches on motivations underlying national identification, their contextual diversity, and implications for future studies.
psychology, developmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper mainly explores the relationship between values and national identity among adolescents, especially among ethnic minority and majority adolescents. The study focuses on how values influence the changes in national identity among Jewish Israeli (majority group) and Arab Israeli citizens (minority group) adolescents through two longitudinal studies. The research found that for the majority of adolescents, conservative values emphasizing status quo maintenance and stability are important drivers of national identity. In contrast, among ethnic minority adolescents, power values, which prioritize pursuit of social status and wealth accumulation, have a stronger correlation. However, both conservative and power values are associated with enhanced national identity. The paper points out that adolescence is a critical stage of identity development and social change, and individual value systems play an important role in this process. Personal values reflect individuals' understanding of the importance of life, while collective identities such as national identity fulfill basic needs such as avoiding uncertainty, belongingness, and self-image enhancement. However, research on how values influence adolescents' collective identities, especially national identity, is relatively scarce. The paper also discusses the potential influence of different cultural backgrounds on the relationship between values and national identity. In the context of Israel, the national identity of ethnic minority adolescents may be more related to social status enhancement, and universalistic values (concern for the well-being of all people) may decrease their national identity. In summary, this study fills a gap in research on the relationship between adolescent values and national identity and suggests directions for future research, including considering the diversity of motivations and differences in different cultural backgrounds.