Daytime cooling efficiencies of urban trees derived from surface temperature are much higher than those for air temperature

Meng Du,Niantan Li,Ting Hu,Qiquan Yang,TC Chakraborty,Zander Venter,Rui Yao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1748-9326/ad30a3
IF: 6.7
2024-03-07
Environmental Research Letters
Abstract:Accurately capturing the impact of urban trees on temperature can help optimize urban heat mitigation strategies. Recently, there has been a widespread use of remotely sensed land surface temperature (T s ) to quantify the cooling efficiency (CE) of urban trees. However, remotely sensed T s reflects heat radiation from the surface of an object seen from the point of view of the thermal sensor, which is not a good proxy for the air temperature (T a ) perceived by humans. The extent to which the CEs derived from T s reflect the true experiences of urban residents remains unclear. Therefore, this study systematically compared the T s -based CE (CE Ts ) with the T a -based CE (CE Ta ) in 392 European urban clusters. CE Ts and CE Ta were defined as the reduction in T s and T a , respectively, for every 1% increase in fractional tree cover (FTC). The results show that the increase in FTC has a substantial impact on reducing T s and T a in most cities during the daytime. However, at night, the response of T s and T a to increased FTC appears to be much weaker and ambiguous. On average, for European cities, daytime CE Ts reaches 0.075 °C %-1, which is significantly higher (by an order of magnitude) than the corresponding CE Ta of 0.006 °C %-1. In contrast, the average nighttime CE Ts and CE Ta for European cities are similar, both approximating zero. Overall, urban trees can lower daytime temperatures, but the impact of their cooling effect, particularly concerning public health implications, is notably amplified when using remotely sensed T s estimates compared to in situ T a measurements. Our findings provide critical insights into the realistic benefits of alleviating urban heat through tree planting.
environmental sciences,meteorology & atmospheric sciences
What problem does this paper attempt to address?