Green Technology Innovation and Enterprise Performance: An Analysis Based on Causal Machine Learning Models

Xuanai Huang,Yaozhong Wang,Ying Chen,Zunguo Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su16062309
IF: 3.9
2024-03-12
Sustainability
Abstract:As increasingly stringent environmental regulations are put into effect, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) concepts are being seamlessly integrated into the core of corporate innovation strategies. Due to the quasi-public product perspective of green innovation, the performance of enterprises as a result of green innovation activities exhibits significant heterogeneity. This heterogeneity exists not only between corporate value and financial performance but also among individual enterprises. This paper is based on a sample of 1510 listed Chinese companies examined from 2013 to 2020 and uses machine learning algorithms and quasi-natural experiments to precisely estimate the causal relationship and mechanisms between green innovation and corporate performance. The findings elucidate several critical aspects of green innovation within the corporate sphere: Firstly, rather than attracting green incentives from financial markets, green innovation activities inadvertently stifle the enhancement of corporate value. Secondly, these activities markedly bolster corporate financial performance, primarily by diminishing operational costs, which in turn elevates the return on assets (ROA). Lastly, of all corporate characteristics examined, enterprise size and equity concentration stand out as key determinants influencing the variability in outcomes of green innovation performance. The above findings provide information on the significant implications of enhancing green technology innovation systems and green incentive mechanisms.
environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
### The Problem the Paper Attempts to Solve This paper aims to explore the causal relationship and mechanisms between green technology innovation and corporate performance. Specifically, based on sample data from 1,510 listed companies in China from 2013 to 2020, the paper uses machine learning algorithms and quasi-natural experimental methods to accurately estimate the heterogeneous causal effects of green innovation on corporate value and financial performance. ### Main Research Questions Include: 1. **Does green innovation help improve corporate value and financial performance?** - The study investigates whether green innovation can enhance a company's market value and financial performance by analyzing the impact of green innovation activities on corporate performance. 2. **What is the significance of the causal effect?** - Through quantitative analysis, the study evaluates the statistical significance of the causal effect of green innovation on corporate performance. 3. **Is there significant individual-level heterogeneity?** - The study explores whether there are significant differences in the performance of different companies in green innovation activities and the reasons for these differences. 4. **Which corporate characteristics affect the causal effect?** - The study analyzes the impact of characteristics such as company size and ownership concentration on the performance of green innovation. 5. **How does the cost mechanism operate?** - The study examines the specific impact of green innovation activities on corporate costs and how these cost changes further affect corporate performance. ### Background and Significance With increasingly stringent environmental regulations, the concepts of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) are gradually being integrated into the core innovation strategies of companies. Due to the quasi-public goods nature of green innovation, its impact on corporate performance exhibits significant heterogeneity. This heterogeneity exists not only between corporate value and financial performance but also among different companies. Therefore, understanding the complex impact of green innovation on corporate performance is of great significance for formulating effective green technology innovation systems and incentive mechanisms. ### Methods and Data The paper employs the latest causal forest machine learning algorithm to overcome the endogeneity issues present in traditional econometric models. The research data comes from green patent application data and other firm-level data of 1,510 listed companies in China from 2013 to 2020. By constructing causal trees, the researchers explore the heterogeneous causal effects of green innovation on corporate performance and introduce multiple covariates (such as agency costs, operating costs, state-owned equity ratio, etc.) to control for other possible influencing factors. ### Main Findings 1. **Green innovation activities inadvertently suppressed the enhancement of corporate value**: - Although green innovation activities can enhance a company's financial performance, they have not attracted green incentives from the financial market and have, to some extent, suppressed the enhancement of corporate value. 2. **Green innovation significantly improved corporate financial performance**: - By reducing operating costs, green innovation activities significantly increased the company's return on assets (ROA). 3. **Company size and ownership concentration are key factors affecting the performance of green innovation**: - Among all the examined corporate characteristics, company size and ownership concentration have the most significant impact on the performance of green innovation. ### Conclusion Through multidimensional heterogeneity analysis, this study provides a detailed review of the achievements and shortcomings of corporate green innovation. The research results not only enrich the research perspective of green innovation theory but also provide new ideas for promoting the value growth of Chinese companies. Additionally, the study provides important references for the government in formulating green innovation policies.