Abstract:This article reviews economic studies based on data from high income countries published from 2007 to early 2024 to address three questions: (1) How accurate are subjective beliefs, mainly measured by subjective probabilities, compared to their objective counterparts? Objective evidence comes from another source (e.g., life table, empirical study, expert opinion), or subsequent realizations of beliefs elicited at baseline. (2) How are subjective beliefs determined? (3) Do subjective beliefs affect health behaviors? Several domains are included: survival, and health behaviors—smoking, alcohol consumption and impaired driving, preventive care, diet, and COVID-19 precautions. Results on a single domain, (e.g., survival), do not generalize to, e.g., COVID-19 results. Subjective probabilities embody private information (e.g., self-assessed health, parent longevity). However, individuals seem insufficiently informed about population-level probabilities. There is no systematic overestimation or underestimation of objective probabilities. Several determinants of beliefs are identified (demographic characteristics, education, cognition, current self-assessed health, health histories), but evidence on underlying mechanisms is lacking, how determinants, (e.g., education), affect beliefs. Subjective beliefs, even with substantial noise, often affect health behaviors. Given prior evidence that beliefs are influenced by health shocks, this article reviews research on effects of health shocks on health behaviors. A major health shock to an individual—a new diagnosis (e.g., diabetes) or a serious adverse health event (e.g., heart attack), by changing subjective probabilities leads to some healthier behaviors, however, sometimes only temporarily. Behaviors may also be influenced by utility loss following a health shock, e.g., learning about pecuniary and non-pecuniary costs of hospitalization.

A behavioral gap in survival beliefs

Consumption Behavior, Annuity Income and Mortality Risk of the Elderly

Socioeconomic position and the association between anticipated and actual survival in older English adults

Optimism and survival: health behaviors as a mediator—a ten-year follow-up study of Chinese elderly people

The influence of mortality and socioeconomic status on risk and delayed rewards: A life history theory approach.

Health and Education: Understanding the Gradient

Age differences in the neural basis of decision-making under uncertainty

MEDICAL VERSUS FINANCIAL RISKY DECISION MAKING IN OLDER AND YOUNGER ADULTS

Stability and change of optimism and pessimism in late midlife and old age across three independent studies.

The evolution of social behaviors and risk preferences in settings with uncertainty

Private Information and Misinformation in Subjective Life Expectancy

Survival with ambiguity

The Impact of Distorted Longevity Risk Cognition on Financial Preparation for Retirement

Human aging alters social inference about others’ changing intentions

Frailty-based mortality models and reserving for longevity risk

Unexpected longevity, intergenerational policies, and fertility

Subjective beliefs, health, and health behaviors

Eudaimonic wellbeing and life expectancy

Individual-specific mortality is associated with how individuals evaluate future discounting decisions

An Economic Theory of Depression and its Impact on Health Behavior and Longevity

Optimal choice of health and retirement in a life-cycle model