Evidence for variations in cryogenic extraction deuterium biases of plant xylem water across foundational northeastern US trees

Matthew Sobota,Kevin Li,Michael Hren,James Knighton

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/hyp.15079

IF: 3.784

2024-02-04

Hydrological Processes

Abstract:Through a series of tree core rehydration experiments, we demonstrated that xylem water 2H cryogenic vacuum extraction (CVE) biases varied significantly with plant water status and species identity. We further demonstrated that different conclusions on water uptake of neighboring hemlock and pine are reached when assuming: (1) no bias correction, (2) a generic bias correction ignoring species‐level variations, and (3) a bias correction accounting for species‐level variations. This research demonstrates an urgent need for the critical evaluation of CVE for plant water extraction. Measurements of oxygen and hydrogen isotopes in plant xylem water (2H, 18O) have helped to redefine conceptual and numerical models of the hydrological cycle and understand how plants compete for subsurface water. Recent experiments have shown that Cryogenic Vacuum Extraction (CVE) of plant xylem water can result in a δ2H bias. We tested if CVE δ2H‐biases varied significantly across seven foundational northeastern US forest trees with a series of tree core rehydration experiments. Our analysis demonstrated that CVE δ2H‐biases were well predicted by sample gravimetric water content and varied significantly with tree species identity. We show that species‐level δ2H‐bias corrections can result in substantially different understandings of plant water uptake and transpiration versus uncorrected data or generic bias corrections. This research demonstrates an urgent need for the critical evaluation of CVE for plant water extraction. In the absence of a stronger understanding of CVE δ2H‐biases, we recommend that xylem water δ2H observations should not be used in plant water uptake studies.

water resources