Abstract:Numerous quantitative ultrasound imaging techniques have demonstrated superior monitoring performance for thermal ablation when compared to conventional ultrasonic B-mode imaging. However, the absence of comparative studies involving various quantitative ultrasound imaging techniques hinders further clinical exploration. In this study, we simultaneously reconstructed ultrasonic Nakagami imaging, ultrasonic horizontally normalized Shannon entropy (hNSE) imaging, and ultrasonic differential attenuation coefficient intercept (DACI) imaging from ultrasound backscattered envelope data collected during high-intensity focused ultrasound ablation treatment. We comprehensively investigated their performance differences through qualitative and quantitative analyses, including the calculation of contrast-to-noise ratios (CNR) for ultrasonic images, receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis with corresponding indicators, the analysis of lesion area fitting relationships, and computational time consumption comparison. The mean CNR of hNSE imaging was 10.98 ± 4.48 dB, significantly surpassing the 3.82 ± 1.40 dB (p < 0.001, statistically significant) of Nakagami imaging and the 2.45 ± 0.74 dB (p < 0.001, statistically significant) of DACI imaging. This substantial difference underscores that hNSE imaging offers the highest contrast resolution for lesion recognition. Furthermore, we evaluated the ability of multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging to detect thermal ablation lesions using ROC curves. The area under the curve (AUC) for hNSE was 0.874, exceeding the values of 0.848 for Nakagami imaging and 0.832 for DACI imaging. Additionally, hNSE imaging exhibited the strongest linear correlation coefficient (R = 0.92) in the comparison of lesion area fitting, outperforming Nakagami imaging (R = 0.87) and DACI imaging (R = 0.85). hNSE imaging also performs best in real-time monitoring with each frame taking 6.38 s among multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging. Our findings unequivocally demonstrate that hNSE imaging excels in monitoring HIFU ablation treatment and holds the greatest potential for further clinical exploration.

Improvement of contrast ratio between cavitation bubbles and tissue by frequency filtering in triplet pulse ultrasound imaging

The Relationship of Cavitation to the Negative Acoustic Pressure Amplitude in Ultrasonic Therapy

P3C-12 Combining Spectral and Intensity Data to Identify Regions of Cavitation in Ultrasound Images; Application to HIFU

Interaction Between Encapsulated Microbubbles: A Finite Element Modelling Study

Expansion of cavitation region using ultrasound focus scanning in the direction of ultrasound propagation for efficient method of histotripsy

High-Speed Ultrasound Imaging of Laser-Induced Cavitation Bubbles

Real-Time Monitoring and Quantitative Evaluation of Cavitation Bubbles Induced by High Intensity Focused Ultrasound Using B-Mode Imaging

Medical ultrasound with microbubbles

Formation Process of Thermal Damage in a Target Area of High Intensity Focused Ultrasound and Effectiveness Analysis of B-ultrasound Real-Time Monitoring

Dynamic Mode Decomposition for Transient Cavitation Bubbles Imaging in Pulsed High Intensity Focused Ultrasound Therapy

Effect of intended shift in propagation direction of cavitation generation position on coagulation position in bubble-enhanced ultrasonic heating

Dual frequency Ultrasonic Cavitation in Various Liquids: High-Speed Imaging and Acoustic Pressure Measurements

A comparative study on detection of polymer-shelled microbubbles by different excitation pulses.

Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound Imaging Based On Bubble Region Detection

A Sensitive Ultrasonic Imaging Method for Targeted Contrast Microbubble Detection

Detection of High Intensity Focused Ultrasound Induced Cavitation Activity in Liver Tissue

Enhanced HIFU Theranostics with Dual-Frequency-Ring Focused Ultrasound and Activatable Perfluoropentane-Loaded Polymer Nanoparticles

Multiple ultrasonic parametric imaging for the detection and monitoring of high-intensity focused ultrasound ablation

Microbubble detection on ultrasound imaging by utilizing phase patterned waves

30Mhz High-Frequency Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound and Super-Resolution Imaging Using Long-Lasting Microbubbles

Post-processing Radio-Frequency Signal Based on Deep Learning Method for Ultrasonic Microbubble Imaging