Unveiling urban governance diversity: Clustering cities based on mitigation actions

Sombol Mokhles,Kathryn Davidson,Michele Acuto
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s13280-024-01991-z
IF: 6.94
2024-03-29
AMBIO
Abstract:Embracing a "more global" urban comparison in scientific assessments of climate actions by cities is essential to drive greater and more inclusive participation in global efforts to curb climate change. This comparison needs to engage cities irrespective of their size and status: when we do so, distinctive patterns of urban climate mitigation actions across a diverse range of cities emerge. Employing K-means clustering as a pattern recognition method, this study compares cities based on selected aspects of their reported mitigation actions to the Carbon Disclosure Project. It explores whether the identified clusters facilitate the comparison of a socio-spatially diverse range of cities. The study identifies five clusters within two themes, namely the nature and finance–implementation of actions, shedding light on shared and distinct governance aspects of mitigation actions by cities. Notably, the study underscores how governance patterns transcend city size and global status. These findings offer valuable insights for broadening the comparative imagination of cities and inter-city networking opportunities.
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper aims to address the diversity of urban climate governance and reveal governance patterns in climate mitigation actions across different cities through cluster analysis. Specifically, the paper attempts to: 1. **Expand the understanding of diverse urban climate governance pathways**: By adopting a "more globalized" approach to city comparison, the study goes beyond traditional global city classifications, focusing on cities of different sizes and statuses, particularly those often overlooked small cities and cities in the Global South. 2. **Identify governance patterns in urban climate mitigation actions**: Using the K-means clustering algorithm, the study explores the similarities and differences of mitigation actions reported by cities to the Carbon Disclosure Project (CDP). The research identifies 5 clusters and categorizes them into 2 themes: the nature of actions and the financing and implementation conditions. 3. **Promote broader network exchanges among cities**: By revealing governance patterns in different cities, the study helps to break the inequalities in existing network practices, enabling more small cities to participate in global climate actions, thereby promoting more comprehensive climate change response strategies. Overall, this paper aims to advance more inclusive urban climate governance research and practice, emphasizing the diversity and complexity beyond city size and global economic status.