Contents analysis of thyroid cancer-related information uploaded to YouTube by physicians in Korea: endorsing thyroid cancer screening, potentially leading to overdiagnosis

EunKyo Kang,HyoRim Ju,Soojeong Kim,Juyoung Choi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-024-18403-2

IF: 4.5

2024-04-02

BMC Public Health

Abstract:Abstract Background Thyroid cancer overdiagnosis is a major public health issue in South Korea, which has the highest incidence rate. The accessibility of information through the Internet, particularly on YouTube, could potentially impact excessive screening. This study aimed to analyze the content of thyroid cancer-related YouTube videos, particularly those from 2016 onwards, to evaluate the potential spread of misinformation. Methods A total of 326 videos for analysis were collected using a video search protocol with the keyword “thyroid cancer” on YouTube. This study classified the selected YouTube videos as either provided by medical professionals or not and used topic clustering with LDA (latent dirichlet allocation), sentiment analysis with KoBERT (Korean bidirectional encoder representations from transformers), and reliability evaluation to analyze the content. The proportion of mentions of poor prognosis for thyroid cancer and the categorization of advertising content was also analyzed. Results Videos by medical professionals were categorized into 7 topics, with “Thyroid cancer is not a ‘Good cancer’” being the most common. The number of videos opposing excessive thyroid cancer screening decreased gradually yearly. Videos advocating screening received more favorable comments from viewers than videos opposing excessive thyroid cancer screening. Patient experience videos were categorized into 6 topics, with the “Treatment process and after-treatment” being the most common. Conclusion This study found that a significant proportion of videos uploaded by medical professionals on thyroid cancer endorse the practice, potentially leading to excessive treatments. The study highlights the need for medical professionals to provide high-quality and unbiased information on social media platforms to prevent the spread of medical misinformation and the need for criteria to judge the content and quality of online health information.

public, environmental & occupational health

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

This paper aims to analyze the content of thyroid cancer-related videos uploaded to YouTube after 2016, particularly those provided by medical professionals, to assess whether these videos contain misleading information when disseminating information about thyroid cancer screening. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects:

1. **Overdiagnosis Issue**: Overdiagnosis of thyroid cancer is a major public health issue in South Korea, especially after the incidence rate exceeded 80% in the early 2010s. Despite the South Korean government issuing thyroid cancer screening guidelines in 2015, the incidence of thyroid cancer steadily increased again between 2015 and 2020. Therefore, the study seeks to understand whether information on internet platforms (especially YouTube) has influenced over-screening.

2. **Video Content Analysis**: By analyzing the content of thyroid cancer-related videos on YouTube, researchers aim to evaluate whether these videos provide high-quality, unbiased information and whether this information might lead to over-screening. The study particularly focuses on videos uploaded by medical professionals, as these videos may have a greater impact on public health decisions.

3. **Audience Reaction**: The study also analyzes the comments from viewers on these videos to understand their attitudes towards videos supporting or opposing thyroid cancer screening. This helps to understand the public's acceptance and potential misunderstandings of thyroid cancer screening information.

4. **Advertising Content**: The study also categorizes videos containing advertisements, particularly those from insurance companies, which may encourage thyroid cancer screening. This helps to assess whether commercial interests play a role in promoting over-screening.

### Main Findings

1. **Video Content**: A significant proportion of videos uploaded by medical professionals support thyroid cancer screening, and these videos mention poor prognosis of thyroid cancer at a higher rate. In contrast, videos uploaded by non-professionals mention poor prognosis of thyroid cancer at a lower rate.

2. **Audience Reaction**: Videos supporting thyroid cancer screening received more positive comments, while videos opposing over-screening received more negative comments. This indicates that viewers are more likely to believe information supporting screening, even if it may be inaccurate.

3. **Advertising Content**: Among the videos containing advertisements, the majority were from insurance companies, which typically encourage thyroid cancer screening.

### Conclusion

The study found that a considerable portion of thyroid cancer-related videos uploaded by medical professionals support thyroid cancer screening, which may lead to over-screening. The study emphasizes the importance of medical professionals providing high-quality, unbiased information on social media to prevent the dissemination of misleading medical information. Additionally, the study highlights the need for standards to evaluate the quality and content of online health information.