Abstract:Policy interventions are frequently used by authorities around the world to mitigate carbon emissions. However, economic systems are essentially complex adaptive systems, which often exhibit unexpected responses to exogenous interventions and leave intervenors in a dilemma, even if the interventions are elaborately designed. To explore the behaviors of the diffusion system regarding low-carbon technologies, this study builds an agent-based model (ABM) to simulate enterprises’ reactions to multiple policy interventions aimed at spurring low-carbon technology diffusion. The simulated enterprises are in a complex network where they play evolutionary games with their neighbors, which enables the model to possess two critical features of economic systems: adaptiveness and equilibrium. The model reveals a dilemma of policy interventions: intuitively, carbon taxes, asymmetric penalties (only imposed on un-low-carbon enterprises) and subsidies can improve the diffusion, which is consistent with previous research; counter-intuitively, all these policies turn out to be inefficient or even harmful to low-carbon enterprises because of the diffusion system’s high adaptiveness. Specifically, when carbon taxes and penalties increase, both the low-carbon and un-low-carbon enterprises end up with the equilibrium of equivalent but lower profits. In contrast, all the enterprises earn equivalent but more profits even though subsidies are only given to the low-carbon enterprises, which implies that the un-low-carbon enterprises (indirectly) grab a portion of the subsidies and accordingly weaken the incentive effect of subsidies. These system behaviors are summarized as “equalizing effect” because the system tends to equalize the impact of both positive and negative interventions among all enterprises even though the policy interventions are asymmetrically imposed on one type of the enterprises. The findings also indicate that policies implemented to enlarge green market sizes can help policymakers bypass the dilemma.

Evolutionary Game and Simulation Analysis of Low-Carbon Technology Innovation with Multi-agent Participation

Evolutionary game analysis of green technology innovation under the carbon emission trading mechanism

Government regulation, horizontal coopetition, and low-carbon technology innovation: A tripartite evolutionary game analysis of government and homogeneous energy enterprises

The Evolutionary Game Analysis of Multiple Stakeholders in the Low-Carbon Agricultural Innovation Diffusion

The Evolutionary Game Simulation on Technology Innovation between Government and Small and Medium-sized Enterprises

Evolutionary game analysis of low-carbon transformation and technological innovation in the cold chain under dual government intervention

Spontaneous Formation of Evolutionary Game Strategies for Long-Term Carbon Emission Reduction Based on Low-Carbon Trading Mechanism

Evolutionary Game Theoretic Analysis of Low Carbon Investment in Supply Chains under Governmental Subsidies

Tripartite Evolutionary Game Theory Approach for Low-Carbon Power Grid Technology Cooperation with Government Intervention

An evolutionary analysis of low-carbon technology investment strategies based on the manufacturer-supplier matching game under government regulations

Stability Analysis of Low-Carbon Technology Innovation Cooperation under a Reward and Punishment Mechanism

Incentives for Green and Low-Carbon Technological Innovation of Enterprises Under Environmental Regulation: From the Perspective of Evolutionary Game

Evolutionary Game Analysis of New Energy Transition Among Government, Traditional Automobile Enterprises, and Research Institutions Under the Dual Carbon Goals

Evolutionary game and simulation analysis of enterprise's green technology innovation under green credit policy: evidence from China

Evolutionary Game Analysis of Carbon Emission Reduction between Government and Enterprises under Carbon Quota Trading Policy

Exploring the Dynamics of Low-Carbon Technology Diffusion among Enterprises: an Evolutionary Game Model on a Two-Level Heterogeneous Social Network

Study on Low-Carbon Technology Innovation Strategies through Government–University–Enterprise Cooperation under Carbon Trading Policy

Tripartite evolutionary game and simulation analysis of governments, enterprises, and consumers under a carbon-generalised system of preferences

Evolutionary game analysis on the selection of green and low carbon innovation between manufacturing enterprises

Simulating Policy Interventions in the Interfirm Diffusion of Low-Carbon Technologies: an Agent-Based Evolutionary Game Model

A tripartite evolutionary game study of low-carbon innovation system from the perspective of dynamic subsidies and taxes