Abstract:Immersive virtual reality (VR) technology has the potential to play an important role in the conceptual design process in architecture, if we can ensure that sketch-like structures are able to afford an accurate egocentric appreciation of the scale of the interior space of a preliminary building model. Historically, it has been found that people tend to perceive egocentric distances in head-mounted display (HMD) based virtual environments as being shorter than equivalent distances in the real world. Previous research has shown that in such cases, reducing the quality of the computer graphics does not make the situation significantly worse. However, other research has found that breaking the illusion of reality in a compellingly photorealistic VR experience can have a significant negative impact on distance perception accuracy. In this paper, we investigate the impact of "graphical realism" on distance perception accuracy in VR from a novel perspective. Rather than starting with a virtual 3D model and varying its surface texture, we start with a live view of the real world, presented through a custom-designed video/optical-see-through HMD, and apply image processing to the video stream to remove details. This approach offers the potential to explore the relationship between visual and experiential realism in a more nuanced manner than has previously been done. In a within-subjects experiment across three different real-world hallway environments, we asked people to perform blind walking to make distance estimates under three different viewing conditions: real-world view through the HMD; closely registered camera views presented via the HMD; and Sobel-filtered versions of the camera views, resulting a sketch-like (NPR) appearance. We found: 1) significant amounts of distance underestimation in all three conditions, most likely due to the heavy backpack computer that participants wore to power the HMD and cameras/graphics; 2) a small but statistically significant difference in the amount of underestimation between the real world and camera/NPR viewing conditions, but no significant difference between the camera and NPR conditions. There was no significant difference between participants' ratings of visual and experiential realism in the real world and camera conditions, but in the NPR condition participants' ratings of experiential realism were significantly higher than their ratings of visual realism. These results confirm the notion that experiential realism is only partially dependent on visual realism, and that degradation of visual realism, independently of experiential realism, does not significantly impact distance perception accuracy in VR.

Real and virtual environments have comparable spatial memory distortions after scale and geometric transformations

Effect of Interaction Characteristics of Virtual Environments on Spatial Representation

Frontal Extents Are Compressed in Virtual Reality

Can Spatial Biases Be Eliminated Through Learning?

Testing memory of a VR environment: comparison with the real environment and 2D pictures

Manipulating objects during learning shrinks the global scale of spatial representations in memory: a virtual reality study

Comparing Spatial Navigation and Human Environment Interaction in Virtual Reality vs. Identical Real Environments across the Adult Lifespan

Comparing spatial navigation in a virtual environment vs. an identical real environment across the adult lifespan

Reference frames in virtual spatial navigation are viewpoint dependent

Spatial Knowledge Acquisition in Virtual and Physical Reality: A Comparative Evaluation

Cognitive Maps for a Non-Euclidean Environment: Path Integration and Spatial Memory on a Sphere

The influence of spatial dimensions of virtual environments on attitudes and nonverbal behaviors during social interactions

Egocentric Distance Perception: A Comparative Study Investigating Differences Between Real and Virtual Environments

Category boundaries modulate memory in a place-cell-like manner

The influence of spatial size of indoor VR environments on preference evaluation

Impact of visual and experiential realism on distance perception in VR using a custom video see-through system

What Prevents Us From Learning Virtual Reality Space: A Study of Indoor Corridor Angle and Obstacle Transparency

No advantage for remembering horizontal over vertical spatial locations learned from a single viewpoint

Wayfinding Behavior and Spatial Knowledge Acquisition: Are They the Same in Virtual Reality and in Real-World Environments?

Walking through doorways causes forgetting: Further explorations

Comparing physiological responses during cognitive tests in virtual environments vs. in identical real-world environments